= 27
NGO, non-governmental organisation.
‘We are short [staffed] so two people cannot go on holiday at the same time, so it's such an inconvenience and … we are trying to cover the days, nights and it's like wrrrr … really stressful place to be … ’ (female, 24, NGO).
Working conditions were the main cause of stress regardless of the sector people worked in; people working in the NGO or the public sector more often referred to the physical environment and workloads as relevant factors. Private sector employees more often referred to long working hours and a lack of structure to the working day.
A similar number of participants ( n = 40) suggested that the nature of the job itself contributed to stress, with participants from private organisations and NGOs more often reporting this as a cause of stress. Participants attributed stress more specifically to a job with high unpredictability in what may be required from day to day, or a job that demands unsociable hours.
‘Shift work … I find that quite stressful because it affects my personal life because I have to work during the weekends and that's when most of my family and friends are off … ’ (female, 26, NGO).
Management practice was proposed as a cause of stress by more than half of the interviewees ( n = 32), but was least often implicated in the public sector organisations. Participants in high managerial positions (e.g. head of unit) tended to refer to management practice as a cause of stress less often than employees in non-managerial positions. However, for all other participants (e.g. middle management positions and employees) no differences were observed. Management practice as a cause of stress related to personal style of leadership, implicating lack of warmth and support with a feeling that staff were unimportant and not respected as people; insufficient praise or confidence-building were also important omissions that caused stress. Limited opportunities for decision-making (often referred to as low decision latitude) and lack of transparency as well as unrealistic demands, poor communication and effort–reward imbalance were all implicated.
‘That's what makes you angry, because there's nobody taking my case. As soon as this phone goes to my boss and they complain about me, nobody asks me what happened. And even if I'm right, they still apologise. Why? I've done nothing wrong. It's them. They've done the wrong thing’ (male, 45, public). ‘ … the message the organisation gives to you is that you don't really matter’ (female, 40, NGO).
Life events were identified as another contributor to the level of stress experienced by employees regardless of the type of organisation they worked for ( n = 21). Life events referred to problems with family or relationships, death and sickness, as well as trying to maintain a balance between work demands and responsibilities in the social and personal or family lives of respondents.
A small number of respondents ( n = 6) reported financial factors as a cause of work stress; financial strain causing work stress was related to working for organisations that lacked a benefits package, or in which the salary did not reflect the amount of effort invested in work. Job insecurity as a cause of work stress reflected fears about losing income and facing further financial strain.
Individual and organisational stress management interventions
Participants were asked about any interventions at their workplace for managing stress. Overall, participants referred less frequently to individual interventions; such interventions were also either secondary or tertiary. In particular, they were either psychological interventions such as face-to-face telephone or internet counselling, or educational interventions or training courses that taught practical skills such as organisational management and assertiveness ( Table 2 ).
Organisation | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Reported as an effective intervention | Public = 27 | Private = 13 | NGO = 11 | |
Individual: psychological interventions | 5 | 3 | 3 | |
1-2-1 therapy, counselling | ||||
Intranet/internet counselling | ✓ | |||
Complementary therapy | ||||
Helpline/telephone coaching | ||||
Individual: education | 1 | 1 | 0 | |
Organisational skills courses | ||||
Assertiveness training | ||||
Organisational: management practices | 20 | 8 | 7 | |
Supportive, approachable, appreciative | ✓ | |||
Communicative | ✓ | |||
Frequent business/staff meetings | ✓ | |||
Supervision | ✓ | |||
2-way feedback | ✓ | |||
Organisational: organisational team culture | 16 | 5 | 6 | |
Space for discussion | ✓ | |||
Dialogue group | ✓ | |||
Pre-/post- group | ✓ | |||
Notice board | ✓ | |||
Organisational: working structure | 10 | 0 | 4 | |
Flexibility | ✓ | |||
Balanced working hours | ✓ | |||
TOIL | ✓ | |||
Fixed days off | ✓ | |||
Well-planned shifts | ✓ | |||
Organisational: education | 14 | 4 | 4 | |
Educational/training courses | ✓ | |||
Inset days | ✓ | |||
Organisational: environment | 9 | 3 | 2 | |
Open-plan office | ||||
Relaxation room | ✓ | |||
Working room | ||||
Organisational: health promotion | 5 | 1 | 0 | |
Gym membership | ✓ | |||
Health promotion courses | ||||
Health promotion activities such as head massage and exercise | ✓ |
NGO, non-governmental organisation; TOIL, time off in lieu.
Some patterns emerged in the use of individual interventions by type of organisation: NGOs were least likely to deliver individual interventions to employees, perhaps owing to cost. In terms of effectiveness, those participants who received one-to-one counselling interventions thought these were effective, mainly because they could be accessed promptly when needed.
‘So [I] went to my [general practitioner] GP and they set it up through my local authority for face-to-face counselling, so I was seeing the occupational therapist, [had] face-to-face counselling and that happened on my day off. So [I] could do some work at home, because I was very tired I didn't have the stress of having to get into work, so just took a bit off. So [it was] kind of a package of things that just assisted me for a while’ (female, 49, public).
Organisational interventions were more often mentioned by workers in public sector employment and in contrast to individual interventions, they were mainly primary or secondary ( Table 2 ). Most of these organisational interventions were related to management practices ( n = 35/51). In particular, participants mentioned efforts to develop a management style that was supportive and improved communication, as well as frequent team meetings and supervision and two-way feedback.
‘[The manager is] one of those people that make you feel appreciated, even if it's a little thing she will praise you for it. A lot goes for being praised, that in itself can take away stress. If someone turns around and says what you are doing is a fantastic job you feel good’ (female, 52, public).
A supportive organisational and team culture, a collective spirit including dialogue in groups and space for discussion, and educational and training courses to improve management skills were frequently reported as effective interventions to manage stress at work ( n = 27/51).
‘ … it's good that we all sit down together and discuss anything that may be causing a problem or tension, or anything we feel needs to be adjusted’ (female, 27, public).
Flexibility in working hours, well-planned shifts and environmental or structural interventions such as a staff room for relaxation were mentioned by almost a third of the participants as effective ways of managing work stress. Participants working in private sector organisations rarely report the existence of any interventions related to work structure (e.g. flexibility in work times), whereas in the public sector there was evidence of trying to introduce more flexibility.
‘ … time off in lieu […] seems to work quite well 'cos it's about that work–life balance’ (female, 54, public).
Almost half of participants ( n = 22) said training and career development opportunities in the workplace were effective for managing work-related stress, as they made them feel adequately informed and valued. Appropriate training and adequate equipment and resources allowed employees to perform their roles effectively. A small number of interviewees ( n = 3) suggested training in stress management was a useful intervention.
‘[My manager] is very good at sending people on training courses. I've just been on one which is positive interactions, which was telling you the right way of dealing with situations’ (female, 52, public).
Finally, a small number of participants ( n = 9/51) reported that there were a number of health promotion interventions (e.g. courses, exercise) at their workplace to help them prevent work stress. Participants thought that being subsidised for gym membership or being encouraged by their organisation to exercise during their working day were very effective interventions. None of the participants working for NGOs mentioned health promotion.
‘ … we're quite actively encouraged to do lots of exercise in this trust, we get lots of emails about walking to work, or running … I think linking exercise and well-being and being healthy at work […] I think that's always good, it would be good to have that in every institution’ (female, 28, public).
Participants were asked general questions about their personal strategies to manage work stress. We were interested in personal interventions not provided by their employers but ones that were used and considered effective.
Table 3 shows the types of personal interventions used at work. Some interventions helped employees process stressful thoughts and think through difficult situations, akin to what CBT therapists might suggest as cognitive restructuring and tackling cognitive distortions – for example, focusing on positive rather than stressful situations, and using self-reflection to gain a better perspective.
Effective personal interventions to manage stress at work (total number of respondents: 51)
Intervention | |
---|---|
Cognitive interventions | 23 |
Positivity/mindfulness, not focusing on problems | |
Focusing on problems, self-reflection | |
Replicate/learn from past performance | |
Self-motivation | |
Support | 35 |
Colleague support | |
Family/friend support | |
Health promotion | 24 |
Healthy eating | |
Gym, exercising, sports Yoga, meditation, breathing | |
Structure/organisation | 26 |
Weekends off, breaks | |
Time management, prioritising, not taking work home | |
Work–personal life balance | |
Keep going to work | |
Interests | 31 |
Leisure activities | |
Holidays |
‘Yeah, yeah or if something happens I try and think, erm, so there's another technique I learnt in the last place I worked at was five questions so I ask, the why questions five times, why this? why is it causing stress? … because of this, why is that? Why is that? And I usually get to the root cause and that usually chills me out a bit if I deal with the root cause rather than the thing causing me the stress’ (male, 30, public).
Support from colleagues and friends was the most frequently reported personal intervention for managing stress at work.
‘I actually had to say to a colleague, “I can't see the wood for the trees here, can you help me?” and the colleague was absolutely brilliant and helped me so we got through it. I got some excellent help from a colleague yeah and that was someone I worked with in the team who does the same job as me. My manager was very supportive and helpful as well’ (male, 41, private).
Keeping oneself organised and maintaining a structured schedule at work were thought to be very effective personal interventions. These included planning, reducing overtime, prioritising tasks and keeping a better balance between work and personal life.
‘One of the signals for me is if my desk starts getting a bit messy, it means I'm chasing between too many projects and that's often the time when I personally just take stock, think, right, what do I need to do, look at a priority list, clear the decks again and sort of take a bit of a step back and review. So that's how I manage it and I find that to be helpful for me’ (male, 47, public).
Almost half of the participants ( n = 24) pointed out the importance of a healthy lifestyle when trying to manage stress at work. In particular, exercise was the most frequently reported personal intervention. Participants also acknowledge the importance of healthy eating as a means of maintaining a healthy weight and better health in general, both of which helped people to better manage stress at work.
‘Exercise is the most important thing for me for stress. So yeah, if I'm stressed, as long as I can, I'll often leave work at a decent time and go for a run and come back to work or go take my computer home and go for a swim and then do some more work. As long as I can make sure I can get some exercise in then I'm fine. It kinda works quite good 'cause I can generally take a longer lunch break and go to the gym at lunch and then, you know, work later or whatever it is. That's probably the most important flexibility for me at work is being able to have that’ (female, 32, private).
Finally, having out-of-work interests and leisure activities was reported by more than half of the participants ( n = 31). For example, participants mentioned relaxation during lunch breaks and going on holidays as an effective personal intervention.
‘We do get inspired by going to talks and design galleries and illustration events and all that sort of thing, they're hobbies as much as they are a career but, at the same time, I think that, in a way, [this] helps to alleviate the stress levels at work because what you're doing at work is part of your hobby as well’ (male, 30, private).
A mixture of personal, organisational and individual interventions were reported in our study, but these are not often captured together, with emphasis often being given to workplace changes or separate public health approaches to lifestyle and physical activity. 28 – 30 The majority of individual and organisational interventions reported were secondary and tertiary preventive interventions, with less emphasis on primary prevention.
High-demand and low-control situations and effort–reward imbalance related to working conditions, management style and the type of job were causing distress at work. 12 , 31 , 32 It is also important to address management practices as one of the most significant and consistent work-related stressors. Management practice as a stressor was also more prominent in private and NGO sectors than in the public sector and in middle and low management positions than in higher management ones. Participants identified poor communication with management, unfair treatment and, above all, the feeling of not being appreciated as the biggest sources of stress for them. Furthermore, many participants highlighted working conditions, such as physical environment, unsociable working hours and under-staffing, as causes of their work stress, the harmful effects of which have been identified in previous research. 18 , 33 Financial factors, mainly a lack of financial recognition by the organisation, were also reported as a cause of stress. According to Stranks, 11 when workers experience insufficient rewards in the form of salary or amount of praise received, or are missing recognition, the feeling of devaluation might appear and can contribute to an experience of work stress.
Participants in the present study tended to report mainly the presence of primary and secondary organisational interventions (as opposed to individual interventions) at their workplace. With regard to individual approaches, these were mainly psychological interventions. Although there is much research that has documented the effectiveness of psychological interventions, these are usually provided at the secondary or tertiary level rather than for primary prevention. 34 – 36
Organisational interventions were discussed by the participants more frequently and were also more often perceived as effective in managing stress at work than individual interventions. One of the main reasons that organisational interventions were identified as an effective way of managing stress was because they were primary interventions with the aim to modify or eliminate environmental stressors. Participants in the present study identified the organisational interventions to manage stress at work as: job redesign, change of organisational culture, encouragement of participative management, introduction of work–life balance policies, flexible working and reconstruction of the organisation as well as improvement of organisational communications. 11 The literature on organisational interventions does not identify management practices as an intervention. The main reason may stem from the fact that management is seen as part of organisational structures rather than as potentially subject to modification to manage stress. Our findings highlighted management practices as an important workplace intervention, especially management characteristics such as open communication, supportiveness, approachability and being appreciative; these ranked the highest in terms of perceived effectiveness. Improving management practices as an intervention and introducing flexibility in working structures were much more apparent in the public sector as opposed to the private sector and the NGOs. Content analysis suggested that there may be a relationship between reported causes of stress and individual and organisational interventions. For example, stress was less often reported in the public sector because there were more management interventions than in other sectors, and these were perceived to be effective by the participants.
Most personal interventions identified by participants were related to health behaviours such as exercise, meditation and healthy eating, as well as leisure activities and social support from family and colleagues. Although personal interventions outside the workplace were not considered by the organisations, it is important to emphasise the power of such interventions and that they should be included in future intervention packages. For example, physical activity programmes have been among the few organisational interventions that show convincing effects on absenteeism in accord with our previous reviews, but physical activity could be encouraged more generally. 24 , 30 By adapting organisational interventions to capitalise on and encourage personal individual interventions outside the workplace, stress management in the workplace may be less necessary or more effective where it is needed.
The results suggest that employees in private organisations and NGOs report more perceived causes of stress and have fewer interventions in place to help employees manage stress compared with public sector organisations, notably National Health Service (NHS) employers. We have listed potential organisational, individual and personal interventions that were used and found to be helpful. These might be tested as correlates of better workforce health and well-being and less work stress.
A limitation of the study was related to the sample characteristics. Although there were variations, especially with regard to type, size and location of the organisations involved, the sample consisted of only 12 organisations in total. A larger number of organisations would have provided us with more variety of occupations and organisation size and location, which would have given a more complete picture concerning the causes of stress and interventions between sectors. Our study is exploratory, and although these are perceived causes, the findings should not be understood in terms of epidemiological causal relationships, but rather as important ways in which workers think about and manage work stress, providing clues as to how interventions might be developed, tested and located in these work settings.
Qualitative studies offer new insights and provide the in-depth and experience-near perspectives of participants, rather than an overtheorised and superficial analysis. The findings will contribute to future in-depth work including more varied samples, as well as survey research to test for interventions that correlate with organisational measures of health and well-being. Future work should also consider how to improve management practices, as these seemed to have the most important influence on reducing work stress. More research is needed to further explore the differences between private, public and NGO sectors and different job types such as education and healthcare to examine whether they respond to the same or different intervention techniques. Finally, research needs to take into account compositional effects including the demographic characteristics of samples, and the cost effectiveness of interventions.
General questions to start the interview
Managing stress at work (both managing yourself and other people)
Managing return to work (managing both yourself and other people)
Policies: managing stress at work and return to work
Declaration of interest None.
COMMENTS
Summary. Work stress refers to the process of job stressors, or stimuli in the workplace, leading to strains, or negative responses or reactions. Organizational development refers to a process in which problems or opportunities in the work environment are identified, plans are made to remediate or capitalize on the stimuli, action is taken, and ...
A multi-site, cross-sectional study was conducted to survey employees across four worksites participating in a WorkWell KS Well Being workshop to assess levels of stress and productivity. Stress was measured by the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS) and productivity was measured by the Health and Work Questionnaire (HWQ).
July 05, 2022. LightFieldStudios/Getty Images. Summary. To combat stress and burnout, employers are increasingly offering benefits like virtual mental health support, spontaneous days or even ...
1. Introduction. Ample evidence indicates chronic stress as a risk factor for physical and mental health [].It is for example known that chronic stress at work manifests in poor mental health, such as depression and anxiety [2,3], as well as in in sleep problems [].However, individual differences in the reactions to stress (also referred to as stress reactivity) are seen to be critical in ...
Abstract. Introduction: the choice of strategies to cope with stress has differential effects on individual and organizational outcomes (e.g. well-being and performance at work). This study examined to what extent individuals differing in their positive psychological resources (optimism, hope, self-efficacy and resilience) implement different ...
25. Stress Management in Organization s. Roxana Capotescu. 1. Babe ş-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca. Abstract. Employee stress h as increasingly become a concern for many organizations. Although ...
Furthermore, the work envi-ronment plays a significant contribution in inducing workplace stress because of human physiologic response. Nox-ious stress is detrimental to the human body, especially ...
A stressful work environment can contribute to problems such as headache, stomachache, sleep disturbances, short temper, and difficulty concentrating. Chronic stress can result in anxiety, insomnia, high blood pressure, and a weakened immune system. It can also contribute to health conditions such as depression, obesity, and heart disease.
Nearly 3 in 5 employees reported negative impacts of work-related stress, including lack of interest, motivation, or energy (26%) and lack of effort at work (19%). Meanwhile, 36% reported cognitive weariness, 32% reported emotional exhaustion, and an astounding 44% reported physical fatigue—a 38% increase since 2019.
Workplace Stress Management: 11 Best Strategies & Worksheets. 30 Sep 2021 by Jeremy Sutton, Ph.D. Scientifically reviewed by Anna Katharina Schaffner, Ph.D. Stress is a factor in 7 out of the top 10 causes of death worldwide, and the workplace is an important contributor (Quick & Henderson, 2016). An American Psychological Association survey ...
It can be said that stress management in work settings can be effective in enhancing worker physical and psychologic health, but the choice of which stress-management technique to use should be based on the specific health outcomes that are targeted for change. ... Extension of research into stress factors and their effect on illness ...
Summary. Extensive research focuses on the causes of workplace-induced stress. However, policy efforts to tackle the ever-increasing health costs and poor health outcomes in the United States have largely ignored the health effects of psychosocial workplace stressors such as high job demands, economic insecurity, and long work hours.
The paper examines the relationship between individual, organizational and financial effects of stress. It identifies four problems faced by staff in the workplace: identifying the reasons for ...
If nothing helps and the working environment remains stressful, exercise your avoidance options and get a new job. Job hunting can be stressful, particularly in times of high unemployment, but being ground down day after day by work is far worse. Adapted from The Stress Solution by Lyle H. Miller, PhD, and Alma Dell Smith, PhD.
Chronic stress can also affect health by interfering with healthy behaviors, such as exercise, balanced eating, and sleep. Work stress can also harm companies or organizations. Burnout reduces job productivity and boosts absenteeism and job turnover, and also leads to conflict between coworkers, causing stress to spread within a workplace.
Table 4 shows the manifestation of stress at workplace and its impact to productivity. 5.6 Implementing Stress Management at the Workplace Stress management is an essential action to decrease the negative impacts of work stress. Its approach is for improving workers' overall well-being and productivity (Sutarto et al., 2020).
Set an example by using these resources yourself. Make sure workers are taking regular breaks, and be sure to take them yourself. Encourage employees to exercise daily, take time for friends or a ...
In previous research, quality management has been shown to be related to workplace health (Bäckström et al., Citation 2012; Lagrosen, ... While the effects of quality management on workplace health had been studied earlier, the findings regarding workplace stress and bullying are novel and constitute the originality of this study. The ...
Constantly changing technology. Lack of social support. Insufficient control over job-related decisions. Conflicting job demands and unclear performance expectations. In most cases, multiple stressors combine to produce our work-related stress, differing in severity through the day and even our career.
A third view is that the impact of work stress on employee performance is non-linear and may exhibit an inverted U-shaped relationship (McClenahan et al., ; Hamidi and Eivazi, ); reportedly, when work stress is relatively low or high, employee performance is low. Hence, if work stress reaches a moderate level, employee performance will peak.
Obligations, working conditions, the environment, and other factors related to one's job can all contribute to stress at work. There is widespread agreement that work-family conflict is mostly generated by workplace stress, which has a negative impact on both individual and organizational welfare (Uziel et al., 2019).
In a 2012 U.S. survey, 1.9 percent of 34,525 adults reported that they had practiced mindfulness meditation in the past 12 months. Among those responders who practiced mindfulness meditation exclusively, 73 percent reported that they meditated for their general wellness and to prevent diseases, and most of them (approximately 92 percent) reported that they meditated to relax or reduce stress.
The program's lifestyle changes include exercise, smoking cessation, stress management, social support, and a whole-foods, plant-based diet low in total fat. The program is offered by a team of health care professionals who provide the support that individuals need to make and maintain lasting changes in lifestyle.
Music has a unique ability to soothe the mind and body, and I find that it reduces my stress and anxiety levels. Some research has suggested that music can lower cortisol (stress hormone) levels ...
Managing stress at workplace. Ashok Panigrahi. Associate Professor, Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies, NMIMS University, Shirpur. Email: [email protected]. Abstract. Stress is ...
R&D Management journal addresses the interests of practising managers and academic researchers in research and development and innovation management. ... A Research Agenda for Workplace Innovation: The Challenge of Disruptive Transitions. Edited by Peter R. A. Oeij, Steven Dhondt, Adela J. McMurray, ...
The conceptualisation of work stress is of crucial importance when developing interventions for the workplace. Work-related stress is defined as 'a harmful reaction that people have to undue pressures and demands placed on them at work'. 1 As many as 440 000 people in the UK complain of work-related stress, depression or anxiety that makes them ill; nearly 9.9 million work days were lost ...
The authors thank the associate editor and the referees for many helpful comments that led to improvements in the paper. The authors also thank Itay Goldstein (discussant), participants of the 2023 NBER (National Bureau of Economic Research) Summer Institute, the workshop on Systemic Risk and Stress testing at the University of Chicago, Bank of England, and the 2023 AsianFA (Asian Finance ...
About 60% of psychology graduates work in management, community and social services, education, healthcare, and administrative support, showcasing the versatility of their skills. The demand for mental health professionals is rising, with an expected increase of 71,500 jobs for counselors in substance abuse, behavioral disorders, and mental ...
A free NHS health check programme has been rolled out to more than 130,000 people in workplaces across the UK from 30 August, the government has announced.. With the aim of "boosting economic growth by improving the health of the nation" and cutting waiting lists, the checks will ensure workers are better protected from conditions such as heart disease, kidney disease and diabetes.