Inbound Insurance Marketing

Insurance Case Studies: The Ultimate Guide

feature image

How do you show your prospects exactly what your company can do for them? With a case study. Insurance case studies provide buyers with the solid facts, figures and performance examples they need to make a purchasing decision.

What Is a Case Study?

A case study is a powerful marketing tool that is often used in the middle or bottom of the sales funnel, to help buyers develop a preference for your offering. Case studies increase buying confidence and validate the buying decision. They prove that your product or service performs as promised.

Case studies change the conversation from telling to showing. Instead of just telling prospects how great your brand is, you can show prospects exactly what your brand is capable of achieving. This gives prospects a more concrete understanding of what to expect and enables them to step into the shoes of a satisfied customer.

The Elements of a Case Study

An effective case study contains key elements that align with the buyer’s journey:

  • Who is the customer? If you don’t have permission to name the customer, describe the customer by industry, size and other relevant details.
  • What problem were they trying to solve? When B2B buyers are shopping for a product, they’re trying to solve a specific problem. Identify this problem so other prospects with similar problems can relate. Sometimes, there’s more than one problem.
  • What other solutions did they consider? B2B buyers usually consider multiple options before deciding. This is a key part of the process, and including the details can help emphasize why your company stood out.
  • Why did they choose your solution? State exactly what your company offered that other competitors couldn’t.
  • What was the implementation process like? Switching B2B vendors can be a major undertaking. Describe the process so your prospects will know what to expect. Of course, you want to put your company in a positive light and focus on the positives, but you can include hiccups that occurred in the process and how you handled them. Prospects know that things don’t always go perfectly according to plan, and this shows that you’re competent and able to overcome any barriers that arise.
  • How has the company benefited? In the beginning of the case study, you described the client’s problem. Now touch back on this and show how the problem has been solved. Include specific information about how the company has benefited from your product or service. For example, how much time or money has the client saved? How are they better prepared? How have you helped increase their revenues?
  • What are the key takeaways for others in a similar situation? Convince prospects that they should follow the client’s example and partner with your company. Summarize your argument with key takeaways from the case study.

Case Study Dos and Don’ts

To squeeze the most value from your case study, you need to follow some best practices.

  • Don’t just list bulleted facts. You might be able to pull a list of bulleted facts from your case study to use in other types of content, such as social media posts, but your actual case study should be at least two pages long to tell the story in a meaningful way.
  • Do use names. Your case study will carry a lot more weight if the featured customer is named. You can also use anonymous case studies, but they are not quite as credible.
  • Do appeal to emotions. Think of your case study as a story. You’re showing your prospects what it’s like to work with your company, so you need to build a narrative. This is also a good place to build an emotional argument by showing how your company can help clients deal with pain points and reduce problems.
  • Don’t make your case study longer than it needs to be. Your prospects are busy, and they probably won’t have time to read an overly verbose document. Provide enough information to create a compelling story, but don’t get bogged down with unnecessary details. An effective case study will often be around two pages.
  • Do include quotes. You can say that your company is great, but it sounds more convincing if one of your customers says it. The featured customer may be willing to provide you with quotes and their logo to include in your case study. As a bonus, this is also free publicity for them.
  • Do get permission. If you’re naming a customer, you will need to secure their permission and allow them the opportunity to review and approve the final piece before it is used. Be sure to save their written approval in case questions arise in the future.

Case Studies Should Be Part of Your Content Library

Creating a case study can take some time and effort, but they are worth it.

According to the 2022 Edelman Trust Barometer , 63% of people worry business leaders are trying to mislead people with false or exaggerated statements. If you just say that your company can help people solve their problems, your prospects might not believe you. You need to build credibility, and a case study that provides concrete examples can help.

A case study is also a fantastic way to differentiate yourself from your competition. As mentioned earlier, case studies are often used in more advanced stages of the customer journey, when prospects are already familiar with your company and need information that’s going to guide their purchasing decision. You want to create preference for your company so you can close the sale, and a case study can help you do that.

Your Case Study Can Convert Leads for Years

Some content has a short life, but not case studies. Although creating a case study will require some effort, once you have it, you can use it for as long as you continue to offer the featured products and services, and the featured company is still a customer.

  • Feature your case study on your website. You can create a landing page for your case study or case studies so prospects can find them easily. They can be offered as instant downloads or you can generate leads by gating them with a form.
  • Promote your case study in social media posts. Spread the word about your case study on social media. You can always just write a post and link to the case study, but also consider designing graphics for the case study. A LinkedIn carousel post is another great way to highlight your case study on social media.
  • Encourage prospects to download the study as a call to action in your blog posts . This is a practical way to encourage your audience to learn more about your company.
  • Link to case studies in email nurturing campaigns . If you’re nurturing a prospect that has downloaded other content, a case study link can entice additional engagement.
  • Build case studies into your sales processes . Sales professionals love using case studies as handouts as they provide a great springboard for meaningful conversations.
  • Use content to develop webinars or videos . You can even use case study content as the foundation for very powerful webinars or videos.

Need Case Studies but Don’t Know Where to Start?

Inbound Insurance Marketing can help your company develop powerful, effective case studies. Learn more. Or, if you’re ready to get started, schedule 30 minutes to discuss your project.

Share this Article:

Please fill out the form below for business, media and press inquires. For HR inquires, visit the careers page

Thanks For Reaching Out!

We look forward to talking soon.

Blog | Insurance

  • Insurance Digital Transformation: Improving the Customer Experience

In this insurance digital transformation case study, our design thinking practice drives impactful results to the client's bottom line and customer experience.

JANUARY 29, 2018

case study for insurance

As data analytics transform the global business community at a rapid pace, many opportunities exist for insurers to leverage information to grow their bottom line. All insurance companies are sitting on a wealth of information about their customers and operational processes. The biggest challenge insurers face with this data? There’s too much data to sort through, and it’s difficult and time consuming to translate information into actionable insights.

Making your data work harder – and more valuable -- is what the Sutherland Cloud Analytics platform is all about. It has positively impacted many companies on a global scale, combining the power of data analytics with artificial intelligence (AI) to drive insights to fuel decisions that boost your bottom line and customer experience.

Harnessing Big Data Drives Insights, Streamlines Processes

Guardian Group , an integrated financial services organization with a focus on life, health, property and casualty insurance, pensions and asset management, recently partnered with Sutherland to rapidly monetize its data assets to meet their business needs.

Prior to engaging Sutherland, the leading insurer was challenged with disparate, unsynchronized databases and inconsistent data across their organization, and basic financial and operational reporting did not deliver valuable information for executive decision making. The time was right for Guardian Group to make agile adjustments to address changing customer expectations, market needs, and regulatory mandates.

Sutherland’s Cloud Analytics Platform and associated consulting established an ongoing big data capability to facilitate a culture of leveraging insights for business decisions. Thanks to Sutherland’s cloud-based solutions, Guardian Group saw an approximately 25 percent reduction in manual efforts and associated labor cost for some activities, 20 percent reduction in claims-related processing turnaround time, and 100 percent digitization of forms now available online.

An End-to-End Analytics Transformation

Core components of the data analytics solution for Guardian Group include:

Suspense Amount Management for cloud: AI-leveraged analytics that enables insurers to wade through complex data streams and meaningfully allocate premium suspense amounts to the right policies. It’s designed to optimize cash flows to improve loss ratios, combined ratios, and current ratio.

Operational Lapse Accounts Analytics to better understand agent performance and drive optimal account management processes.

Operational solutions to help drive efficiencies and automation in customer-facing and claims management processes.

Precise customer service and predictive modeling powered by analytics capable of turning customer and market behaviors into models.

Strategic customer, agent, and policy profitability analytics to assess emerging risks, identify new revenue sources and optimize enterprise-wide profitability.

Now is the time to leverage data analytics to your drive competitive advantage and positively transform processes throughout your insurance organization.

Reduce Risk. Gain Advantage. Improve Retention.

Share this:

Sutherland Editorial

Let's connect on:

symbol

Explore Insights

  • Business Process Services
  • Business Process Transformation
  • Consulting Services
  • Content Services
  • Customer Interaction Services
  • Digital Engineering Services
  • Digital Finance
  • Insight & Design
  • Products x Platforms
  • Sutherland Labs
  • Transformation Engineering
  • Banking and Financial Services
  • Communications, Media & Entertainment
  • Energy and Utilities
  • Mortgage Services
  • Oil and Gas
  • Retail and Consumer Packaged Goods
  • Travel, Transportation, Hospitality & Logistics
  • Case Studies
  • Infographic
  • Solution Overview

Related Insights

case study for insurance

Whitepaper | Insurance

Beyond the Hype: How AI Is Transforming Insurance Claims

Learn how you can strategically embed AI into your P&C claims process to improve performance, increase efficiency, and reduce error, fraud, and costs for measurable business results.

case study for insurance

Case Study | Insurance

40% Reduction in Claims Processing Time for Leading Online Homestay Marketplace

Learn how Sutherland is helping a top global online marketplace for homestays and experiences build future scalability by reimagining their claims value proposition.

case study for insurance

Webinar | Insurance

Reimagining the TPA: Making Digital Human

In this webinar, insurance industry experts cover how a transformative TPA model can boost CX and drive efficiencies.

case study for insurance

Redefining Third Party Administration(TPA) With Experience-Led Digital Transformation

Uncover the answer to the L&A insurance industry’s problems: digital TPAs. Learn how a digital TPA model can deliver personalized experiences, streamline claims, and accelerate business growth.

case study for insurance

Navigating the Triple Threat: Security, Speed, and Scalability in TPA Operations

Join experts from Sutherland, Newgen, LiDP, and Woodmen Life as they explore the solutions and strategies you need to drive L&A operational success.

case study for insurance

Insurance TPA: New Partner in L&A Business Agility

Third-party administrators have gone from being ‘predictable run’ partners for L&A companies to a new model of being partners in strategic growth initiatives, panelists from Celent, Ameritas and Sutherland discussed in an IIR webinar sponsored by Sutherland.

case study for insurance

How to Fortify Third-Party Administrators (TPAs) Against Cyber Risks

L&A insurers today can’t afford the severe consequences of cybersecurity breaches. However, not all TPAs are created equal. Discover what you should look for from a secure, digital TPA that can protect your data and operations.

case study for insurance

Claims Transformation for Leading Personal Lines Insurer

Explore how a top insurer reduced costs and improved topline growth with Sutherland’s transformative claims solution.

case study for insurance

Embracing a Digital-First Ecosystem in the Life and Annuity Insurance Space

As the insurance sector journeys further down the path to digitization, the importance of a digital-first ecosystem for life and annuities cannot be ignored. Find out why.

case study for insurance

Leveraging User Behaviors for Operational Excellence in Insurance

Insights gleaned from user behaviors can help insurers streamline processes, enhance customer experiences, reduce risk, and drive innovation. Find out how.

case study for insurance

Navigating Disruption: Innovation and Change Management in the Insurance Industry

The traditional model of insurance is being reshaped forever. However, its transformation will not be straightforward. Discover the hurdles insurers must overcome to thrive in the face of disruption.

case study for insurance

Transforming Claims Servicing: Enhancing the Future of Life & Annuity Insurance Customer Experience

Discover the technological, customer, and industry changes driving claims transformation for the life and annuities sector.

case study for insurance

Unveiling the Hidden Gems: Attracting New Talent to the Insurance Industry

From embracing innovation to leveraging digital platforms, the insurance sector is trying to shake off its traditional image, undergoing a transformation to attract new and high-quality talent.

case study for insurance

Transforming the Insurance Customer Experience: Understanding and Executing Transformation

Our report, in partnership with HFS, uncovers the state of insurance CX. Highlighting insights from 400 industry leaders, learn about insurers' common mistakes and concerns and the way forward.

case study for insurance

Discover how modern TPAs can support rapid product development and digital customer experience.

case study for insurance

Video | Insurance

Interview: Hiscox USA CEO on Why Sutherland Is the Perfect Digital Transformation Partner

Hear from Hiscox USA CEO Kevin Kerridge on how partnering with Sutherland propelled this small commercial insurer to the top spot in the U.S.

case study for insurance

Podcast | Insurance

Insurance Sync with Bobbie & Laurel

This podcast series explores the latest insurance trends and challenges by interviewing industry thought leaders.

case study for insurance

Solution Overview | Insurance

Insurance Reimagined With Digital-First Operations

Sutherland TPA-Edge goes beyond traditional TPAs, delivering end-to-end efficiencies, conversions, and cost savings with best-in-class partnerships and unbeatable industry expertise.

case study for insurance

Ordinary to Exceptional: Unpacking the Insurance Customer Experience Evolution

In the era where superior service is pivotal for client retention, the auto insurance sector stands on the verge of a profound transformation towards innovative customer experiences, emphasizing the need for tech-driven solutions.

case study for insurance

Global Insurance Broker Reduces Test Effort by 75% and Improves Compliance with CloudTestr

A leading insurance broker cut costs and time to market while improving compliance by automating and streamlining its testing function with Sutherland’s CloudTestr.

case study for insurance

Global Insurer Reduces OpEx Costs and Turnaround Times Across Multiple Geographies and Languages

In a decade-long partnership, Sutherland helped this insurer and reinsurer establish underwriting centers of excellence, cutting submission clearance turnaround by half, and shortening handle times by 20%.

case study for insurance

Large, Diversified Reinsurer Unlocks Value Transforming Legacy Processes and Scaling Underwriting Operations

This reinsurer improves turnaround times and speed to market with underwriting support and real-time analytics from Sutherland.

case study for insurance

Largest U.S. P&C and Life Online Agency Boosts Their Annual GPW Sales

Discover how an insurance agency enhanced their ability to pre-qualify leads with Sutherland.

case study for insurance

Leading Fortune 500 Insurer Achieves 20% Operating Cost Efficiencies

Learn how a prominent P&C player gained end-to-end automation with Sutherland CATS

case study for insurance

Direct-to-Consumer Life Insurer Supercharges Their Growth With A Scalable Operating Model

How an insurance provider boosted their growth and customer experience by leveraging multiple Sutherland’s advanced solutions.

case study for insurance

An Insurtech Start-up and SMB P&C Carrier Wanted to Redefine the Future of CX in Insurance, and Achieved Best-In-Class Service Metrics While Reducing Operating Costs

AI-driven insurance company partners with Sutherland to jump-start digital-first customer experience in a hugely competitive market segment.

case study for insurance

Top Life and Annuities Insurer Revolutionizes Their Sales Operations And Achieves Significant Growth

Sutherland's scalable, customer-first approach helped leading insurer drive year-on-year sales improvement.

case study for insurance

Top Supplemental Insurer Skyrockets Annual Revenue and Boosts Closing Rate by 30%

Discover how America’s most recognized brand in supplemental insurance supercharged cross-sells to 1.6 products per member with Sutherland.

case study for insurance

Top US P&C Agency Enhances Their End-to-End Small Commercial Accounts Management

Discover how this insurer increased the profitability and growth of small accounts book of business by driving operational efficiency

case study for insurance

World’s Largest Insurer for Classic Cars Takes a Digital-First Approach to Drive Best-in-Class Experiences

Learn how Sutherland digitally transformed the classic vehicle insurer’s operating model, helping achieve greater alignment with customers in a niche market.

Case studies: Innovation journeys with four leading auto insurers

By Diane Injic, Dorothy Kelly

Many auto insurers find that to compete and grow profitably in today’s market, they need to work smarter with innovative digital tools that bolster profitability and improve the customer experience. Our recently published case studies describe the journeys of four insurers with Verisk’s personal and commercial auto solutions.

inline

Customer stories demonstrate four keys to greater competitiveness.

Here’s a sampling of the challenges and results; read the complete studies to learn more:

  • A leading auto insurer sought to cut unnecessary spending on risks without a history of claims and proof of prior insurance through the phased implementation of a new solution. See how a calculated deployment strategy better enabled the insurer to verify existing or lapsed coverage and make informed decisions on ordering full loss history reports—all before proceeding with a quote.
  • A large national insurer wanted to expand its well-established usage-based insurance (UBI) program and support behavior-based discounts at point of sale. Learn how the Verisk Data Exchange TM helped meet the insurer’s needs for connected car telemetry from consenting drivers, and how the insurer developed and brought to market an expanded UBI program.
  • A major national insurer was seeking more targeted spending on motor vehicle reports (MVRs) and more resiliency in its capacity to verify a risk’s driving history. See how Verisk’s unique driving history tools helped deliver robust access to driving record details, including an innovative MVR Risk Indicator for evidence-based guidance on ordering full MVRs.
  • A leading commercial auto insurer approached Verisk about improving profitability by better understanding each vehicle’s radius exposure at quote. Discover how Verisk’s unique RadiusCheck ® solution helped the insurer identify vehicles that regularly deviated from the declared radius classification—and recapture millions of dollars of premium leakage.

These customer stories help demonstrate four keys to success that can help personal and commercial auto insurers accelerate competitiveness: Speed, accuracy, scale, and a great customer experience.

Read our case studies to learn more.

  • Commercial Auto
  • Personal Auto
  • Auto Usage-Based Insurance
  • Personal Auto Underwriting
  • Coverage Verifier
  • Growth and profitability
  • Kreyòl Ayisyen

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

Understanding how insurance works: A case study about Lucy

Students read about how insurance works and then review a case study to see how insurance choices can affect personal finances for a young adult in a rural area.

When you purchase insurance, you are transferring financial risk from yourself to an insurance company.

Essential questions

  • What is the main benefit of choosing to purchase insurance?
  • How do the insurance company and the policyholder share risks and costs?
  • Understand how insurance works
  • Apply insurance policy specifics to a case study to evaluate costs and benefits

What students will do

  • Read about how the insurance process works and discover what roles the insurance company and the policyholders play.
  • Review information about specific types of insurance policy coverage and costs.
  • Evaluate a case study to see how one policyholder’s insurance choices affected her financially.
  • Write an advice email about the value of insurance in that policyholder’s life.

Download activity

Teacher guide.

cfpb_building_block_activities_understanding-how-insurance-works-lucy_guide.pdf

Student materials

cfpb_building_block_activities_understanding-how-insurance-works-lucy_worksheet.pdf

cfpb_building_block_activities_what-is-insurance_handout.pdf

Note: Please remember to consider your students’ accommodations and special needs to ensure that all students are able to participate in a meaningful way.

Explore related resources

  • Search for related CFPB activities
  • Find financial education lessons from FDIC
  • View financial education resources from the Federal Reserve

Case Study 4: The Digital Transformation of Insurance

  • First Online: 06 February 2020

Cite this chapter

case study for insurance

  • Hubert Tardieu 6 ,
  • David Daly 7 ,
  • José Esteban-Lauzán 8 ,
  • John Hall 9 &
  • George Miller 10  

Part of the book series: Future of Business and Finance ((FBF))

1619 Accesses

1 Citations

Digital is providing great opportunities for insurance firms. The ability to collect and analyze ever-increasing quantities of data makes it possible to provide insurance that is highly personalised, and AI is enabling claims to be processed faster and more accurately than ever before. However, there are also threats for market incumbents, including the rise of aggregation platforms which can seize control of the customer relationship and relegate insurance providers to mere commodity suppliers. In this case study, we explore these trends, challenges, and opportunities, before finally covering how existing firms can leverage platform-based industry ecosystems.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this chapter

Subscribe and save.

  • Get 10 units per month
  • Download Article/Chapter or eBook
  • 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
  • Cancel anytime
  • Available as PDF
  • Read on any device
  • Instant download
  • Own it forever
  • Available as EPUB and PDF
  • Compact, lightweight edition
  • Dispatched in 3 to 5 business days
  • Free shipping worldwide - see info
  • Durable hardcover edition

Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout

Purchases are for personal use only

Institutional subscriptions

Digital start-ups specialized in the Insurance market (FinTech is used for those specialized in banking).

Earnings Before Interest Tax Depreciation and Amortisation.

A discipline that merges telecommunication engineering and computer science to gather and manage information that enables the tracking and controlling of remote objects.

Electronic devices—usually capable of some data gathering, storage and/or processing capability—which can be worn in clothes or as accessories.

Information Commissioner’s Office. (2019). Intention to fine British Airways £183.39m under GDPR for data breach. https://ico.org.uk/about-the-ico/news-and-events/news-and-blogs/2019/07/ico-announces-intention-to-fine-british-airways/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

Insurance Journal. (2019, October). Blockchain Initiative, B3i, Deploys Cat Excess of Loss Product for January Renewals. https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/international/2019/10/15/545507.htm . Accessed October 26, 2019.

International Fraud Bureau. (2018, February). IFB supports IFED’s warning about ghost broking scams. https://insurancefraudbureau.org/media-centre/news/2018/ifb-supports-ifed-s-warning-about-ghost-broking-scams/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

International Fraud Bureau: Crash for cash. https://insurancefraudbureau.org/insurance-fraud/crash-for-cash/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

Krebson Security. (2019, May). First American Financial Corp. Leaked hundreds of millions of title insurance records. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2019/05/first-american-financial-corp-leaked-hundreds-of-millions-of-title-insurance-records/comment-page-1/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

Lemonade blog. (2017, January). Lemonade sets a new world record. https://www.lemonade.com/blog/lemonade-sets-new-world-record/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

McKinsey. (2018, December). Friends or foes: The rise of European aggregators and their impact on traditional insurers. https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Industries/Financial%20Services/Our%20Insights/Friends%20or%20foes%20The%20rise%20of%20European%20aggregators%20and%20their%20impact%20on%20traditional%20insurers/Friends-or-foes-The-rise-of-European-aggregators.ashx . Accessed October 26, 2019.

McKinsey. (2019, May). A new industry model for insurtech. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/financial-services/our-insights/insurance-blog/a-new-industry-model-for-insurtech . Accessed October 26, 2019.

The Actuary. (2017, December). Strength in numbers. https://www.theactuary.com/opinion/2017/12/strength-in-numbers/ . Accessed October 26, 2019.

Download references

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

Paris, France

Hubert Tardieu

Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, UK

Madrid, Spain

José Esteban-Lauzán

Warrington, Cheshire, UK

West Wittering, West Sussex, UK

George Miller

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Hubert Tardieu .

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

Copyright information

© 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG

About this chapter

Tardieu, H., Daly, D., Esteban-Lauzán, J., Hall, J., Miller, G. (2020). Case Study 4: The Digital Transformation of Insurance. In: Deliberately Digital. Future of Business and Finance. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-37955-1_25

Download citation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-37955-1_25

Published : 06 February 2020

Publisher Name : Springer, Cham

Print ISBN : 978-3-030-37954-4

Online ISBN : 978-3-030-37955-1

eBook Packages : Business and Management Business and Management (R0)

Share this chapter

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

  • Publish with us

Policies and ethics

  • Find a journal
  • Track your research

Asking the better questions that unlock new answers to the working world's most complex issues.

Trending topics

AI insights

EY Center for Board Matters

EY podcasts

EY webcasts

Operations leaders

Technology leaders

EY helps clients create long-term value for all stakeholders. Enabled by data and technology, our services and solutions provide trust through assurance and help clients transform, grow and operate.

EY.ai - A unifying platform

Strategy, transaction and transformation consulting

Technology transformation

Tax function operations

Climate change and sustainability services

EY Ecosystems

EY Nexus: business transformation platform

Discover how EY insights and services are helping to reframe the future of your industry.

Case studies

How Microsoft built a new mobility model for cross-border talent

14 May 2024 EY Global

Private equity

How GenAI is empowering talent at a PE-backed consumer brand

09 May 2024 EY Global

Strategy and Transactions

How carve-outs positioned an automotive giant for future growth

12 Apr 2024 EY Global

We bring together extraordinary people, like you, to build a better working world.

Experienced professionals

EY-Parthenon careers

Student and entry level programs

Talent community

At EY, our purpose is building a better working world. The insights and services we provide help to create long-term value for clients, people and society, and to build trust in the capital markets.

Press release

Vellayan Subbiah from India named EY World Entrepreneur Of The Year™ 2024

07 Jun 2024 Eric J. Minuskin

Extreme E and EY publish Season 3 report, recording 8.2% carbon footprint reduction as female-male performance gap continues to narrow

09 Apr 2024 Michael Curtis

EY announces acceleration of client AI Business Model adoption with NVIDIA AI

20 Mar 2024 Barbara Dimajo

No results have been found

Recent Searches

case study for insurance

Rethink customer experience as human experience

Technology will transform customer experience. Competitive differentiation will come from connecting to what is essentially human. Learn more.

case study for insurance

How can trust survive without integrity?

The EY Global Integrity Report 2024 reveals that rapid change and economic uncertainty make it harder for companies to act with integrity. Read our findings.

case study for insurance

How CEOs juggle transformation priorities – the art of taking back control

EY CEO survey highlights how CEOs consider AI transformation, ESG and M&A to navigate between immediate profits and future sustainability aspirations. Read more.

Select your location

Ey-woman

How a Nordic insurance company automated claims processing

By automating unstructured data, a Nordic insurer increased its operational efficiency and improved customer experience.

  • 1. Better question
  • 2. Better answer
  • 3. Better working world
  • How EY can help

The better the question

How do you leverage AI to streamline insurance claims?

An insurer harnessed AI to streamline operations and boost agent capabilities.

N avigating large volumes of unstructured insurance claims data is a substantial challenge for any insurance company looking to automate repetitive yet complex tasks across its operations. The integration of advanced technologies such as automation and artificial intelligence (AI) has become a pivotal driver for the exponential transformation of insurance organizations.

A leading insurance firm in the Nordics wanted to modernize its claims management process. The current workflow required manual processing of each claim request, a time-consuming series of repetitive tasks which had to be performed by its agents. Amplifying the complexity was unstructured data from various sources, requiring detailed examination and categorization. The spectrum of claims data was also broad and varied, originating from multiple sources such as bills, invoices, cash receipts from pharmacies and local clinics, and medical treatment diagnoses with supporting documents.

Each document required thorough analysis by the agents to extract necessary data that could then be categorized based on the relevance for claim processing. As a result, customer service efficiency suffered; the teams struggled to process claims swiftly due to the limited capabilities of existing technology infrastructure that was ill-equipped to facilitate end-to-end automation.

A transformative approach was necessary. The insurance company engaged with EY teams to analyze its existing tech infrastructure and business needs. The goal was to develop an AI-based solution that could streamline their claims management process, automate routine tasks, and free up their agents to concentrate on building stronger customer relationships. By placing humans at the center of this AI-powered transformation, the company sought to augment the agents' capabilities, enhancing their performance and job satisfaction.

This strategy extended beyond a technological upgrade. It was about empowering their people, preparing them for a future where they can collaborate effectively with AI to drive impactful results. This initiative aimed to set the stage for the insurer's expansion into new markets, with their AI-powered claims management solution acting as a catalyst.

Woman and man talking in modern office.

The better the answer

Transforming insurance claims with human-centric AI

An EY solution that transforms the insurer’s data process by converging business insights, domain knowledge and AI.

Transforming the insurer's traditional work environment required a robust, AI-powered solution. Manual handling of claim reimbursements involved laborious tasks like opening individual images and PDF scans, analyzing files, and uploading relevant documents to their systems. EY teams stepped in with EY Fabric Document Intelligence, an AI-powered product, to streamline this process.

Developed by EY wavespace™ Madrid and now integrated into EY Fabric, EY Fabric Document Intelligence is a technology that converts semi-structured and unstructured documents into actionable structured data. Built on machine learning and the Python programming language, the tool is hosted on an EY-secured cloud environment. It was scaled and customized to meet the insurer's specific requirements during the project.

The process was simple yet transformative. Agents uploaded the scanned copies to EY Fabric Document Intelligence, which began image cleansing by detecting relevant data. This involved removing image backgrounds, correcting document rotation and reducing noise to enhance the quality of scanned files. The product then performed preprocessing, document analysis and layout analysis. Using optical character recognition (OCR) and natural language processing (NLP), unstructured data was converted and classified. Finally, the structured data was transferred to the insurer's core claims system.

The product processes more documents over time, the system improves and has the potential to provide continuing value and insights for the insurer. Our team provided a solution that did more than just digitize and organize unstructured data. It combined EY business insights and industry knowledge within a strategic technology ecosystem to help modernize the insurer's operations. EY professionals offered comprehensive services, including solution design, system integration, data science, project management and cloud computing knowledge, with a human-centric approach.

Teams from Sweden, Denmark, Spain, the US and the UK collaborated to integrate EY Fabric Document Intelligence with the insurer's legacy system. They helped the insurer understand that AI, when guided by human insight, serves as a powerful enabler to expedite work.

Financial advisor

The better the world works

Unlocking exponential transformation through AI-driven modernization

The EY team’s AI solution is driving accelerated claim processing, deepened customer relationships, and an enterprise-wide modernization.

The insurance firm now benefits from near real-time processing of claim documents. Since the solution's implementation, a remarkable 70% of the documents fed into the system are correctly extracted and interpreted. This crucial upgrade not only expedites decision-making but also allows agents to concentrate their efforts on enhancing customer interactions. Agents have more time to spend with their customers in providing personalized advice. This shift toward more meaningful engagements cultivates stronger relationships, maintaining trust and driving additional business value. The solution is designed in a way that it gives the required control of the automation and AI technologies to the insurance firm. The data is entered into the system and the output is driven through a controlled set of confidence levels avoiding blackbox implementation of AI. As the client was closely involved in all decision-making, they have sufficient transparency to the solution.

The AI solution has also been instrumental in facilitating the insurer's global expansion goals. The operational efficiency and customer service enhancements resulting from the implementation are sparking curiosity in other areas of the organization. The insurer is now actively exploring further modernization opportunities, recognizing the long-term business value of aligning with the right technology.

The EY-tailored solution has not only streamlined the insurer's processes but also served as a catalyst for reimagining their entire enterprise. The implementation has demonstrated how advanced AI can fuel exponential transformation in the industry, augment human capabilities, and create significant value. With EY and the insurer collaborating to place humans at the center of this AI transformation, the result is a long-term solution that empowers individuals and drives meaningful impact across the organization.

Navigate your AI journey

Build confidence, drive value and deliver positive human impact with EY.ai – a unifying platform for AI-enabled business transformation.

How EY can Help

Artificial Intelligence Consulting Services

Our Consulting approach to the adoption of AI and intelligent automation is human-centered, pragmatic, outcomes-focused and ethical.

EY Nexus for Insurance

A transformative solution that helps accelerate innovation, unlocks value in your ecosystem and powers frictionless business. Learn more.

Finance Transformation in insurance

EY teams help insurers transform finance functions to become active leaders and value creators for the entire business.

case study for insurance

Fredrik Andren

Photographic portrait of Sini Penttinen

Sini Penttinen

EY Logo footer

  • Connect with us
  • Our locations
  • Legal and privacy
  • Open Facebook profile
  • Open X profile
  • Open LinkedIn profile
  • Open Youtube profile

EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients.

case study for insurance

The New Equation

case study for insurance

Executive leadership hub - What’s important to the C-suite?

case study for insurance

Tech Effect

case study for insurance

Shared success benefits

Loading Results

No Match Found

Digital case study

Insurance claims estimator uses AI for efficiency

How insurance claims estimators can use AI to increase efficiency, reduce cycle time and improve customer experience

Our Role: PwC helped an insurtech company use AI and analytics to speed up their claims estimation process. Industry: Financial Services , Fintech Services: Emerging Tech , Artificial Intelligence Digital , Technology

Can the insurance claims estimate generation process be optimized and scaled to support exponential growth?

The insurance industry has experienced its share of technological disruption over the past ten years. As widespread smartphone adoption made it easier for consumers to submit images of collisions in support of auto insurance claims, insurance carriers were deluged, further bogging down an already frustrating and time consuming process. Where others saw chaos, our client saw an opportunity. They hired a team of experienced estimators and auto body experts and started to evaluate photos of auto damage for carriers as a service.

Drawing on their collective experience, the team would look at the photos and provide insurance companies with a preliminary assessment of the damage to the vehicle. Our client was filling a void in the industry, and their business exploded. They now service over 70 insurance companies and are a significant player in the insurtech space. Their challenge was that there are only so many experienced estimators and auto body experts available for hire, and at the rate the company was growing, they knew their growth would soon be constrained by limited resources.

Our client knew that using artificial intelligence (“AI”) and image recognition technology was a possible solution. It could address their scaling challenge and help them continue to improve customer experience. They built a data science team as a start. But then quickly found that building trust in the AI-assisted system, both for their estimators and customers, was key to making this approach successful.

Analyze the estimation process, leverage insertion points for PwC’s Analytics and AI solutions and focus on building trust with the estimators through “explainable AI”

The process

The client is laser-focused on enhancing customer experience. PwC’s AI and Analytics team realized that improving the efficiency, quality, accuracy and consistency of the estimation process would have a major positive impact on their insurance company clients and policyholders through a decrease in claim resolution time. The initial project scope was to work with the estimation team to look at the estimation process involving images and determine whether an AI model could detect which parts of individual vehicles had been damaged based on submitted photos. Automating this previously manual process was an important first step in our collaboration.

PwC’s Analytics & AI Transformation Solution

Working together with the client’s data science team and estimators, we helped create three AI models. The first was to detect and classify car damages from the images, isolating where in the image there was damage and what type of damage was represented. The second model translated damage into individual parts affected by adding additional information to the analysis, such as parts lists for damaged subassemblies, etc. The third model retrieved images of similar vehicles, both damaged and undamaged, to help estimators evaluate whether or not the part was actually damaged. The estimators were pleasantly surprised with the accuracy and depth of the results. The AI model was even catching details that estimators had missed through the manual process. So far, so good.

Building trust in the AI model

Now for the hard part. The ability of an AI model to accurately interpret images was only half of the equation. The AI model needed to be trusted by the estimators as an important augmentation of their analysis. To address this, we partnered with our client’s data scientists to implement an “explainable AI” (XAI) technique. We then used it in a novel way, showing visually why the model arrived at a particular prediction by making analytical determinations at every stage in the process. By doing this, we greatly increased trust in the model as well and demonstrated its value to the data scientists, the estimators, the insurance companies and the insurance company’s clients

“Our client’s experience is a further indication that it’s not about AI replacing human activity, but rather AI aiding and augmenting human activity. And for that to happen, humans need to trust the machine.” Anand Rao PwC Partner

PwC partnered with our client to use explainable AI to improve customer experience and establish trust in the system for its estimators.

The company’s explainable AI model was a game changer as It enabled the following:

  • empowered auto claim estimators to identify where to focus attention during an assessment
  • provided approaches for sharing knowledge among the estimator team to accurately determine which group should handle specific estimates
  • identified 29% efficiency savings possible with full implementation of proof of concept models across the estimator team
  • reduced rework and improved customer experience through reduced cycle times

Through this unique approach to explainable AI, the company has offered a powerful example to the industry of the potential power of AI-assisted processes. They now have concrete validation that an AI-assisted approach works and has the potential to improve other aspects of their overall process. The company has a clear model for growth and a foundation for scalability.

Let us be part of your success story

Reach out to start a conversation

Anand Rao

Partner, PwC US

Francois Ramette

Francois Ramette

‎‎Partner, PwC US

Related content

Boston scientific boosts efficiency and job satisfaction with robotic process automation.

Bots crush the timeline with an 85% reduction in time spent on manual tasks.

Love at first byte: Automating revenue recast helps a technology leader beat the clock

In this case study PwC used robotic process automation (RPA) to expedite the ASC 606 revenue recognition compliance timeline and assist with validations.

Larry  Patrick

Larry Patrick

Principal, PwC US

Tel: (404) 561 1985

Linkedin Follow

Thank you for your interest in PwC

We have received your information. Should you need to refer back to this submission in the future, please use reference number "refID" .

Required fields are marked with an asterisk( * )

Please correct the errors and send your information again.

By submitting your email address, you acknowledge that you have read the Privacy Statement and that you consent to our processing data in accordance with the Privacy Statement (including international transfers). If you change your mind at any time about wishing to receive the information from us, you can send us an email message using the Contact Us page.

© 2017 - 2024 PwC. All rights reserved. PwC refers to the PwC network and/or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details.

  • Data Privacy Framework
  • Cookie info
  • Terms and conditions
  • Site provider
  • Your Privacy Choices

Society-Logo-Tagline

AGENT LOGIN

HOLDER LOGIN

FIND AN AGENT

Case Studies

Protect your bottom line with prompt claims reporting.

The timing of when you choose to report an incident to your insurance carrier has a direct effect on the bottom line. This case study demonstrates how prompt claims reporting was key to recouping this property loss quickly and efficiently. Read More>

Timely Reporting of Workers Compensation Claims

Employers are busy. Injuries are unexpected events that take time from production and can disrupt the normal workflow for everyone involved. However, taking time to report a workers compensation claim as soon as possible will reap rewards. It allows your insurance company to complete a timely investigation, preserve evidence that may be otherwise discarded, and document the facts while the information is fresh in the minds of those involved. Most importantly, it allows your insurance company the opportunity to start building a rapport with your injured worker immediately. Read More>

Workers Compensation and Subrogation – Recovering Money and Lowering Premiums

Handling workers compensation claims is no easy task. Some cases are very complicated, as well as very expensive. And every state’s laws regarding the payment of workers compensation claims is different. To add to that challenge, each state’s laws also differ somewhat as to how an insurance company may recoup some or all of the benefits paid. It is sometimes possible to recover money through the process of subrogation when the work-related injury was the fault of an independent responsible third party. Read More>

Recovering from Property Damage and Employee Injury

At about 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday, July 23, 2014, a patron was leaving a pub in southeastern Wisconsin. Intending to pull straight out of his parking stall, he accidently put his vehicle into reverse and accelerated, backing into the building and caving in the wall. Meanwhile, inside the pub, an employee was serving drinks from behind the bar, which is near a cooking area with a broaster. Suddenly, scalding hot grease erupted from the broaster, splashing everything nearby. The vehicle had hit the wall that contained the cooking equipment, causing serious injuries to the pub employee and significant damage to the building. Read More>

bIlling questions?

 call 888-576-2438 , ext. 5522, or email [email protected] ..

More From Forbes

Whole life insurance in a lifetime financial plan: the case study.

  • Share to Facebook
  • Share to Twitter
  • Share to Linkedin

Click here to read the previous article in this series.

For these comparisons , I create a case study for a forty-year-old married couple with two children who are now constructing a lifetime financial plan. Jerry and Beth have determined that it is time to get serious about retirement and life insurance planning. Jerry is employed and Beth is a homemaker. These gender roles could be switched, but since life insurance is less expensive for women because of their heightened longevity, having the male be the worker is the more conservative case to consider. Jerry is seeking an additional amount of life insurance death benefit equal to $500,000. This, along with his other life insurance, will be adequate to support his family in the event of his death prior to age sixty-five.

Jerry presently has $60,000 saved in a 401(k) plan with his employer, which is invested with an equity glide path strategy representative of a typical target date fund: 80 percent stocks to age forty-five, 65 percent stocks from forty-five to fifty-four, 50 percent stocks from fifty-five to sixty-four, 40 percent stocks from sixty-five to seventy-four, and 30 percent stocks thereafter. He would like to plan for retirement at sixty-five. I will investigate a portion of his assets to be saved in the future that is equivalent to 401(k) employee contribution limits in 2019 with assumed inflation adjustments: $19,000 can be saved each year until age fifty, and then $25,000 thereafter until age sixty-five to account for the allowed catch-up contributions at those ages.

These contribution limits are inflation-adjusted such that real savings are kept the same, but the nominal amounts increase. Because life insurance premiums are fixed without inflation adjustments, the percentage of the savings directed to insurance decreases over time in real terms. Jerry expects to be in a combined 25 percent marginal tax bracket (22 percent for federal taxes and 3 percent for state taxes) in both his preretirement and postretirement years.

For investment returns, I follow the approach explained in Exhibit 3.11 from Chapter 3. Stock returns are simulated with a randomized risk premium above the fixed 3 percent bond yield. That risk premium has a 6 percent average value with a 20 percent volatility. Inflation is fixed at 2 percent annually. This implies a 1 percent real interest rate. Interest rate risk is eliminated from the analysis, as there is no possibility for fluctuating interest rates to create capital gains or losses for the underlying bond portfolio. The risky asset is based on large-capitalization stocks in the United States. Overall, this represents a 9 percent arithmetic average for stocks (7 percent in real terms). The compounded real growth rate for stocks is 5 percent. The investment portfolio is modeled using 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations for investment returns based on these capital market expectations. I assume investors earn these returns net of any investment or advisory fees. As investments are held in tax-deferred accounts, there is no further tax drag to worry about. Investors earn the gross returns and portfolio distributions are taxed as income.

The Best Options For Senior Life Insurance

Types of life insurance policies.

Life insurance is priced using the 3 percent interest rate and the Social Security Administration 1980 cohort life tables for mortality. Pricing for the term and whole life policies was provided in Exhibits 7.1 and 7.2 . Income annuities are priced in the same manner using the Society of Actuaries mortality data as explained in Chapter 4 , assuming an annual 2 percent cost-of-living adjustment for payments to match the assumed inflation rate. In Chapter 4, the income annuity was priced for females. It offered a 4.56 percent payout rate.

In this case study, we use income annuities for males and couples, and we must also account for the fact that the annuity will not be purchased for twenty-five years. The corresponding payout rates for males and couples with annuities purchased today are 4.83 percent and 3.93 percent, respectively. However, with the longevity improvements assumed by the Society of Actuaries over the next twenty-five years, the male and joint income annuity payout rates at that time are 4.47 percent and 3.75 percent, respectively. These latter numbers are what I use. It makes sense to use different mortality tables to price the life insurance and annuities on account of the different populations that use these financial products. Annuity owners will tend to live longer.

To better understand the impacts of investment volatility on the upside and downside, Monte Carlo simulations are used to create a distribution of outcomes. The exhibits report the 10th percentile, median, and 90th percentile from this distribution. We can interpret the 10th percentile outcome as a bad luck case with poor investment returns. It is possible that retirement outcomes could be even worse, but generally Jerry and Beth could expect better retirement outcomes than seen at the 10th percentile. The median reflects more typical outcomes. It is the midpoint of the distribution, with a 50 percent chance for worse outcomes and a 50 percent chance for better outcomes. These are reasonable outcomes for Jerry and Beth to expect. The 90th percentile is a good luck outcome in which investments perform very well, supporting greater spending and larger account balances.

Note that these results are presented in terms of nominal dollars to avoid reader confusion about why inflation-adjusted dollars are less than nominal dollars. This decision does not impact any comparisons for the relative outcomes between scenarios. However, readers should understand that the purchasing power of a given amount of income or wealth will be less in the future. For today’s forty-year-olds, the real purchasing power of money will be about 60 percent of what it is today at age sixty-five, and about 30 percent of today at age 100, assuming 2 percent inflation.

Click here to read the next article in this series.

Looking for more information? Click here and subscribe to the Retirement Researcher for my weekly newsletter and receive additional articles, resources, and exclusive invitations to upcoming webinars!

*This is an excerpt from Wade Pfau’s book, Safety-First Retirement Planning: An Integrated Approach for a Worry-Free Retirement. (The Retirement Researcher’s Guide Series),  available now on Amazon AMZN

Wade Pfau

  • Editorial Standards
  • Reprints & Permissions

Research insights for the insurance industry

Fresh, relevant, and laser-focused on key insurance trends and concerns, our reports are driven by extensive primary and secondary data from across the industry. Our executive partners provide the detailed analysis and predictions you need to make informed decisions and build for the future.

case study for insurance

AI governance in P&C Insurance

This research report presents ReSource Pro Insights’ observations and perspectives on governing AI technologies, examining key considerations for P&C insurance. Analyzing existing regulations and current carrier approaches to

CONSULTING/ADVISORY CLIENTS

If you are a ReSource Pro Advisory or consulting client, then you can access the report here .

NON CONSULTING/ADVISORY CLIENTS

If you are not a current consulting or advisory client of ReSource Pro, then you can request the research report by filling out the form below.

case study for insurance

CES 2024: The top trends and products for P&C insurance to watch

Each year, ReSource Pro attends the event to evaluate technologies and applications for risk and insurance. This report inerprets developments in 2024 through a series of blogs urging

If you are ReSource Pro Advisory client, then you can access the report here .

case study for insurance

The P&C distribution tech landscape

This report explores recent trends that are shaping the landscape, from vendors taking different paths to revenue to emerging solutions addressing pre-submission challenges. More than just a high-level

Join the research community

We’re shaping sustainable growth strategies for p&c operations from the inside, and we’d love for you to join us. our fast-growing primary research community is built by and for insurance industry professionals., member benefits:.

  • Gain exclusive access to tailored primary research, benchmarking, and industry surveys.
  • Contribute to topic and research development.
  • Participate in brief surveys and get complimentary industry reports ($1,495 – $2,495 value).
  • Receive invitations to exclusive webinars, networking dinners, and events with industry leaders.

Join us and make your mark on the future of the P&C insurance industry.

Our research team.

Mark Breading

Mark Breading

  • North America
  • 28+ years of insurance experience
  • Top 50 Insurtech Influencers, 2024 (InsurTech News)
  • Leaders in Technology Awards - Mentor of the Year, 2024 (Consulting Magazine)

Known for his insights on the future of the insurance industry and innovative uses of technology, Mark consults with insurers on forward-thinking strategies for success in the digital age.

Vinay Shah

  • 30+ years of insurance experience

Vinay advises and leads clients through their digital transformation journey, which includes automation, data, analytics, and core systems transformations. He has over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry leading enterprise-wide digital and data transformation initiatives, delivering operational excellence, and driving organization-wide capability improvements.

Meredith Barnes-Cook

Meredith Barnes-Cook

  • 40+ years of insurance experience

Meredith provides advisory and consulting services to insurance carriers and MGAs. She helps clients identify operational gaps and provides guidance on technology and digital platform selection.

Heather Turner

Heather Turner

  • 8+ years of insurance experience

Heather leads and manages ReSource Pro’s research initiatives. In addition, she supports advisory and consulting clients through rich written content, quantitative and qualitative research, and market trend analysis.

Tom Benton

  • 20+ years of insurance experience

An industry thought leader with experience as an insurance CIO, industry analyst, and consultant, Tom helps insurers prepare for and implement strategic transformation initiatives. His core passion is helping insurers and technology providers create strategic plans to improve customer experience, reduce risks, and increase operational efficiency.

I want to see

  • resources Blog Brochure Case Study Datasheet ebook News One pager Research Report White paper

case study for insurance

The future of embedded insurance: Will it be a...

Ces 2024: the top trends and products for p&c..., 2024 strategic initiatives: plans and progress in..., p&c agency distribution: digital strategies..., a new era of carrier staffing and productivity....

Green background

Eliminating backlogs, boosting efficiency of large...

Top 30 insurance broker increases profitability..., channel strategies and plans for mgas, agency and broker talent strategies in 2023.

case study for insurance

Augment your team with Underwriting Assistance

Let’s work through it together, who we serve, what we think, headquarters.

ReSource Pro LLC 60 East 42nd Street Suite 1500 New York, NY 10165 1-888-577-7552

Inc 5000

© 2024 ReSource Pro

Development by new target, inc

  • STRATEGY Transform your operations
  • PEOPLE Extend your team
  • TECHNOLOGY Optimize your systems
  • PROCESS Improve productivity
  • PROCESS Improve Productivity
  • Our Experts
  • ReSource Pro Summit
  • Our Leadership

American Profession Guide

What are You Looking for?

  • Agricultural
  • Art and Design
  • Business and Financial
  • Construction and Manual Labor
  • Engineering and Technical
  • Information Technology
  • Media and Communication
  • Protective Services
  • Science and Research
  • Service Industry
  • Social and Human Services
  • Transportation and Logistics

Case Studies: Successful Underwriting Strategies

Introduction.

Underwriting is a critical process in the insurance industry, involving the evaluation and assessment of risk before issuing policies. This process determines the terms, conditions, and premiums of insurance coverage. Effective underwriting is essential for maintaining the financial stability of insurance companies while ensuring that policyholders receive fair and appropriate coverage. The importance of underwriting lies in its ability to accurately assess risk and set premiums that reflect this risk. By evaluating various factors such as applicant history, financial status, and potential exposures, underwriters can make informed decisions that balance risk and reward. This not only protects the insurer’s profitability but also ensures that customers are charged premiums commensurate with their risk levels. Successful underwriting strategies often involve a combination of thorough risk assessment, data analytics, and innovative techniques. Underwriters use advanced data analytics to analyze vast amounts of information, enhancing their ability to predict and manage risk effectively. Additionally, implementing a balanced approach helps in setting fair premiums while mitigating potential losses. By applying these successful underwriting strategies, insurance companies can achieve accurate risk evaluation, improve financial stability, and offer competitive coverage options.

Case Study 1: Utilizing data analytics

Data analytics plays a crucial role in the underwriting process, enabling underwriters to make more informed decisions based on data-driven insights. By analyzing vast amounts of data, underwriters can better assess risk levels and potential outcomes.

How data analytics can help underwriters make better decisions

By employing data analytics, underwriters can gather valuable insights into market trends, customer behavior, and risk factors. This information allows them to make more accurate assessments and pricing decisions, resulting in improved underwriting outcomes.

Examples of successful implementation of data analytics in underwriting

  • One insurance company used predictive modeling to analyze customer data and identify high-risk profiles, allowing them to adjust premiums accordingly.
  • Another case study involved a lending institution that utilized machine learning algorithms to automate the underwriting process, reducing manual errors and streamlining operations.
  • A third example showcases a reinsurance company that implemented data analytics to identify patterns in claims data, leading to more efficient claims processing and reduced fraud.

Impact of data analytics on underwriting efficiency and accuracy

The integration of data analytics in underwriting has significantly enhanced efficiency and accuracy in decision-making processes. By leveraging advanced analytics tools, underwriters can access real-time data, perform risk assessments more quickly, and make informed decisions that align with business objectives.

The use of data analytics also enables underwriters to identify emerging trends and potential risks early on, allowing them to proactively adjust their strategies and mitigate potential losses. This proactive approach not only improves underwriting accuracy but also enhances overall risk management practices.

Basically, data analytics has become an essential tool for underwriters looking to optimize their decision-making processes and achieve greater efficiency and accuracy in the underwriting cycle. By harnessing the power of data, underwriters can stay ahead of the curve, minimize risks, and drive sustainable business growth.

Read: HR Specialist vs. HR Manager: Duties, Pay, and More

Case Study 2: Incorporating Technology

In today’s digital age, the role of technology in streamlining underwriting processes has become increasingly vital. With the use of specialized technological tools and software, insurance companies are able to improve their efficiency, accuracy, and overall performance in the underwriting process.

Exploring the Role of Technology

Technology plays a crucial role in automating manual processes, reducing paperwork, and speeding up decision-making processes in underwriting. By leveraging technology, insurers can streamline their operations, enhance customer experiences, and stay competitive in the market.

Specific Technological Tools and Software

  • Underwriting Software: Sophisticated underwriting software applications help underwriters assess risks, price policies, and make informed decisions based on data analytics .
  • AI and Machine Learning: Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning algorithms enable insurers to analyze vast amounts of data quickly and accurately, leading to more precise risk assessments.
  • Blockchain Technology: Blockchain technology enhances security, transparency, and traceability in underwriting processes, reducing the risk of fraud and errors.
  • Telematics Devices: Telematics devices collect real-time data on policyholders’ driving behaviors, enabling insurers to offer personalized pricing based on individual risk profiles.
  • Predictive Analytics: Predictive analytics tools help underwriters forecast future risks, identify trends, and make data-driven decisions to optimize pricing strategies.

Improving Risk Assessment and Pricing

By incorporating technology into underwriting processes, insurers can enhance risk assessment and pricing strategies in the following ways

  • Enhanced Data Accuracy: Technology enables insurers to access, analyze, and validate accurate data, leading to more precise risk assessments.
  • Efficient Processing: Automated underwriting processes reduce manual errors, increase operational efficiency, and accelerate decision-making, resulting in faster policy issuance and better customer service.
  • Personalized Pricing: With advanced data analytics and AI algorithms, insurers can offer personalized pricing based on individual risk profiles, leading to more competitive rates and improved customer satisfaction.
  • Continuous Monitoring: Technology allows insurers to monitor policyholders’ behaviors in real-time, adjust pricing accordingly, and mitigate risks proactively, ensuring long-term profitability and sustainability.

Therefore, the integration of technology into underwriting processes has revolutionized the insurance industry. Enabling insurers to streamline operations, enhance risk assessment, and pricing, and improve customer experiences. As technology continues to evolve, insurance companies must adapt and leverage innovative solutions to stay ahead in a rapidly changing market landscape.

Read: Professional Development: Courses for HR Specialists

Case Study 3: Collaboration with other departments

In the world of underwriting, collaboration with other departments is crucial for success. By working together, different departments can bring their expertise to the table, leading to more comprehensive underwriting decisions.

Benefits of collaboration between underwriting and other departments

  • Enhanced risk assessment: When underwriting teams collaborate with risk management or claims departments, they can better assess potential risks associated with a policy.
  • Improved product development: Collaboration with marketing or product development teams can lead to the creation of new, innovative insurance products that meet the needs of consumers.
  • Efficient processes: Working with the IT department can streamline underwriting processes, making them more efficient and reducing errors.
  • Increased customer satisfaction: Collaboration with customer service departments can help underwriters better understand customer needs and tailor policies to meet those needs.

Successful cross-departmental cooperation in underwriting

One example of successful collaboration is when underwriters work closely with claims departments. By sharing data and insights, underwriters can better assess the risk associated with a policy, leading to more accurate underwriting decisions.

Another example is when underwriters collaborate with product development teams. By understanding market trends and consumer needs, underwriters can design insurance products that are both profitable for the company and valuable for customers.

Collaboration with risk management departments is also crucial. By sharing information about potential risks, underwriters can make more informed decisions about which policies to accept or reject.

Teamwork leading to more comprehensive underwriting decisions

When different departments work together, underwriters can gain a broader perspective on a policy. For example, combining data from claims, risk management, and product development can help underwriters assess the overall risk associated with a policy.

Teamwork also allows underwriters to leverage the expertise of other departments. For instance, working with the IT department can help underwriters incorporate new technologies into their processes, leading to more accurate risk assessments.

Generally, collaboration with other departments is essential for successful underwriting. By working together, underwriters can make more informed decisions, develop innovative products, and ultimately, better serve their customers.

Read: How HR Specialists Navigate Remote Work Challenges

Case Studies: Successful Underwriting Strategies

Case Study 4: Continuous learning and development

Importance of ongoing training and education for underwriters.

Ongoing training and education are crucial for underwriters to maintain expertise. The financial landscape evolves rapidly, demanding continuous skill enhancement. Training helps underwriters stay current with new tools, methodologies, and regulations. Education ensures they can accurately assess risks and make informed decisions. Regular updates improve their understanding of complex financial products and market dynamics. Continuous learning fosters adaptability, helping underwriters respond to emerging challenges. By prioritizing ongoing education, underwriters enhance their performance and contribute to more effective risk management. This commitment to professional development ultimately supports the success of underwriting strategies.

How Underwriters Can Stay Updated on Industry Trends and Regulations

Underwriters must stay updated on industry trends and regulations to remain effective. Attending industry conferences provides insights into emerging trends and best practices. Subscribing to financial journals and newsletters offers regular updates on market changes. Joining professional organizations facilitates networking and access to industry resources. Online courses and webinars provide flexible learning opportunities on regulatory changes and market developments. Following industry leaders on social media keeps underwriters informed about the latest innovations. Regularly reviewing regulatory updates ensures compliance with new laws and standards. Staying informed allows underwriters to adapt strategies and maintain competitive advantage.

Examples of Companies with Successful Training Programs for Underwriters

Several companies excel in providing successful training programs for underwriters. For instance, Prudential offers a comprehensive training program focusing on risk assessment and industry regulations. Their program includes workshops, online modules, and mentorship opportunities. MetLife also invests in continuous education, providing underwriters with access to industry conferences and advanced training seminars. Their program emphasizes both technical skills and industry knowledge. Another example is AIG, which runs an in-depth training program featuring simulations and real-world case studies. This hands-on approach enhances practical understanding. These companies demonstrate the value of robust training programs in developing skilled underwriters.

 Read: The Role of HR in Employee Wellness and Benefits

Successful underwriting strategies are crucial for driving profitability and effective risk management. The case studies presented illustrate a range of successful approaches tailored to specific industries, showcasing their impact on enhancing risk assessment, pricing accuracy, and customer engagement. Each case study highlights how different methods were applied to manage risk effectively and achieve desirable outcomes, leading to improved portfolio quality, reduced loss ratios, and higher customer satisfaction. Key takeaways from these case studies include the importance of customizing underwriting strategies to fit. The unique needs of each industry, as well as the value of leveraging data and analytics to refine risk assessments and pricing models. These strategies demonstrate that a thoughtful, data-driven approach can lead to significant improvements in underwriting performance. Implementing successful underwriting strategies is essential for achieving consistent and favorable outcomes. By adopting proven methods and learning from industry leaders, underwriters can better manage risk, optimize pricing, and enhance overall performance. This process involves analyzing and integrating best practices into your underwriting processes to align with industry standards and market demands.

User: American Profession Guide

Underwriting for High-Risk Clients

Ethical Considerations in Underwriting

Ethical Considerations in Underwriting

Guide to Insurance Underwriting Software

Guide to Insurance Underwriting Software

Importance of Detail in Insurance Underwriting

Importance of Detail in Insurance Underwriting

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your Name *

Email Address *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Submit Comment

Success Stories

Lansforsakringar partners with Infosys for seamless INSIS upgradation and Digital Transformation

Testimonial

Lansforsakringar partners with Infosys for seamless INSIS upgradation and Digital Transformation

  • a.prlst-para')[this.getAttribute('data-index')].href, encodeURIComponent(this.getAttribute('data-title')));" class="share">

Resolution Life Australasia Navigates its Digital Transformation Journey with Infosys

Resolution Life Australasia Navigates its Digital Transformation Journey with Infosys

Infosys Wingspan Helps Transform Vitech’s Talent Enablement Strategy

Client Testimonial

Infosys Wingspan Helps Transform Vitech’s Talent Enablement Strategy

CAA Partners With Infosys for Its Seamless and Innovative Digital Transformation

CAA Partners With Infosys for Its Seamless and Innovative Digital Transformation

Infosys Secures MS Amlin's digital transformation journey

Infosys Secures MS Amlin's digital transformation journey

NN Life Insurance Company partners with Infosys for its Cloud and Agile Transformation

NN Life Insurance Company partners with Infosys for its Cloud and Agile Transformation

a.s.r. Netherlands partners with Infosys for enhanced operational and business efficiencies

Success Story

a.s.r. Netherlands partners with Infosys for enhanced operational and business efficiencies

Next Generation Data Platform for Americas Leading Insurance Client

Next Generation Data Platform for Americas Leading Insurance Client

Venerable & Infosys: A Strategic Partnership to Launch a New Variable Annuity Company

Client Speak

Venerable & Infosys: A Strategic Partnership to Launch a New Variable Annuity Company

Resolution Life advances its smart growth strategy with Oracle ERP Cloud

Resolution Life advances its smart growth strategy with Oracle ERP Cloud

Wearable Devices - Extending Insurance Offerings to Diabetics

Wearable Devices - Extending Insurance Offerings to Diabetics

Legacy Modernization for Leading Insurer

Legacy Modernization for Leading Insurer

Customized ServiceNow implementation by Infosys helps Swiss Reattain Enhanced IT Capabilities

Customized ServiceNow implementation by Infosys helps Swiss Reattain Enhanced IT Capabilities

Claims Transformation Improves Productivity, Reduces Processing Time by 20%

Claims Transformation Improves Productivity, Reduces Processing Time by 20%

Infosys helped Reduce Cycle-Time to launch new services by 25%

Infosys helped Reduce Cycle-Time to launch new services by 25%

Self-Service Platform for Faster Time-To-Market and Enhanced Customer Satisfaction

Self-Service Platform for Faster Time-To-Market and Enhanced Customer Satisfaction

Enabling a 360 Degree Customer view Increases Servicing Efficiency

Enabling a 360 Degree Customer view Increases Servicing Efficiency

Data-Masking Solution Lowers Risk, Reduces Costs for Leading Global Insurer

Data-Masking Solution Lowers Risk, Reduces Costs for Leading Global Insurer

Improved Efficiency and Significant Cost-Savings through Flexible Managed Services Model

Improved Efficiency and Significant Cost-Savings through Flexible Managed Services Model

Flexible and Agile Service Delivery Platform Elevates Customer Experience

Flexible and Agile Service Delivery Platform Elevates Customer Experience

Trending @infosys.

Reimagining insurance with a comprehensive approach to gen AI

Despite forging ahead with generative AI (gen AI) use cases and capabilities, many insurance companies are finding themselves stuck in the pilot phase, unable to scale or extract value. Jörg Mußhoff  sat down with Cameron Talischi and Khaled Rifai to discuss how organizations can escape “pilot purgatory” by leveraging traditional AI and robotic process automation in addition to gen AI; the importance of reimagining domains such as claims, underwriting, and distribution; and how to address data privacy and security concerns regarding intellectual property (IP) and other issues early on. This transcript has been edited for clarity.

Jörg Mußhoff: To us, gen AI is not just hype. McKinsey has estimated that the total gen AI potential for the global economy is $4.4 trillion. 1 “ Beyond the hype: Capturing the potential of AI and gen AI in tech, media, and telecom ,” McKinsey, February 22, 2024. Many insurance leaders are asking, “How do we get the benefits from first use cases, and how do we scale and make it real across geographies and business models?” Cam, could you start us off by telling us what you see in the overarching trends in gen AI and what applications and domains have the greatest potential impact for clients?

Cameron Talischi: We’ve seen a lot of interest and activity in the insurance sector on this topic, which is not surprising given that the insurance industry is knowledge-based and involves processing unstructured types of data. That is precisely what gen AI models are very good for.

In terms of promising applications and domains, three categories of use cases are gaining traction. First, and most common, is that carriers are exploring the use of gen AI models to extract insights and information from unstructured sources. In the context of claims, for example, this could be synthesizing medical records or pulling information from demand packages. In the context of underwriting for a commercial P&C [property and casualty insurance carrier], this could look like pulling information from submissions that come from brokers or allowing underwriters to more seamlessly search and query risk appetite and underwriting guidelines.

The second category is the generation of content—namely, creative content. Think about it in the context of marketing or personalization. Again, in the context of claims, it’s communicating the status of a claim to a claimant by capturing some of the details and nuances specific to that claim or for supporting underwriters, and it’s communicating or negotiating with brokers. Use cases for coding and software development make up the last category. These are notable given the imperative for tech modernization and digitalization and that many insurance companies are still dealing with legacy systems.

Khaled Rifai: I would add one more in the context of client engagement and self-service. Think about the insured wanting to know whether they’re covered, what the statuses of their claims are, or whether they need to update their addresses or names. Many insurers are still employing people to handle these requests. With the help of gen AI, those tasks can be automated or designed for self-service. I think the long-term effects of gen AI are underrated, and the short-term effects are overrated. And that’s the dilemma many insurance companies and other corporations find themselves in. They want fast results from the benefits of gen AI applications but hesitate to invest in data management, technology modernization, organizational change, and budgetary allocations.

While we believe in the potential of gen AI, it will take a lot of engagement, investment, and commitment from top management teams and organizations to make it real. To make gen AI truly successful, you must combine gen AI with more-traditional AI and traditional robotic process automation. These technologies combined make the secret sauce that helps you rethink your customer journeys and processes with the right ROI.

Want to subscribe to the McKinsey on Insurance podcast?

Jörg Mußhoff: That’s exactly what we’re seeing many players do. But we are still in that pilot phase. Why do organizations get stuck in this phase, and how can they successfully scale up from there?

Cameron Talischi: We are seeing a lot of organizations getting stuck in what we call “pilot purgatory” for several reasons. One is misplaced focus on technology versus what matters from a business perspective. Many organizations have identified several use cases and have development teams building these assets. But a lot of time is being spent on testing, analyzing, and benchmarking different tools such as LLMs [language learning models] even though the choice of the language model may be dictated by other factors and, ultimately, has a marginal impact on performance.

While there’s value in learning and experimenting with use cases, these need to be properly planned so they don’t become a distraction. Conversely, leading organizations that are thinking about scaling are shifting their focus to identifying the common code components behind applications. Earlier, we talked about extracting information from unstructured sources. Typically, these applications have similar architecture operating in the background. So, it’s possible to create reusable modules that can accelerate building similar use cases while also making it easier to manage them on the back end.

Another area where organizations get stuck is how they think about impact. We’ve seen many organizations source ideas from various parts of the business and prioritize them. But many of the use cases are very isolated and don’t generate much value, so the organization prolongs the pilot. If you’re not seeing value from a use case, even in isolation, you may want to move on. The better approach to driving business value is to reimagine domains and explore all the potential actions within each domain that can collectively drive meaningful change in the way work is accomplished. So that includes looking at all the levers at your disposal, not just gen AI. That approach better lends itself to scaling versus piloting an isolated use case.

Khaled Rifai: I fully agree. Reimaging domains is key because you can very quickly get to the restrictions connected to isolated use cases because of the dependencies with other systems and processes. We are at a point in time with gen AI where we should take a step back and really reimagine claims, underwriting, and distribution. By combining these technologies and thinking about how to design processes that capture the right data at the right point, we can drive meaningful change. This approach requires investments in more than just tech; it also takes quite some commitment, quite some investment, and quite some change to do so.

About QuantumBlack, AI by McKinsey

QuantumBlack, McKinsey’s AI arm, helps companies transform using the power of technology, technical expertise, and industry experts. With thousands of practitioners at QuantumBlack (data engineers, data scientists, product managers, designers, and software engineers) and McKinsey (industry and domain experts), we are working to solve the world’s most important AI challenges. QuantumBlack Labs is our center of technology development and client innovation, which has been driving cutting-edge advancements and developments in AI through locations across the globe.

Jörg Mußhoff: Do you have any pragmatic advice for our clients about what they should do to set this up and develop these capabilities over time?

Cameron Talischi: Everything must be anchored in a strategic vision and a road map, but in terms of capabilities, the data setup is critically important, especially as you think about gaining scale. You need to make sure that the data underpinning the possible use cases are in usable condition. We talked about the technology stack and this notion of creating infrastructure that can build and deliver use cases at an accelerated pace. You are touching on talent and operating models, which are equally important. One of the failures of some operating models is when the effort is solely tech-led versus business-led with the technology function as an enabler. It’s important to assess how much of the development is done centrally versus within the business.

You shouldn’t wait it out, because you need to build that muscle to understand what solutions you should buy. Khaled Rifai

On the talent side, organizations will most likely pursue a combination of building and buying: purchasing some of the capabilities and use cases from external vendors and building some internally, such as use cases that tie to your IP and ways of working. To build internally, you’ll need the requisite talent to create those capabilities. For example, new roles such as prompt engineers address how we interact with models and get the right behavior out of them. You need to build that muscle and some of those capabilities through a combination of tech and business to deploy them as part of the right operating model.

Khaled Rifai: Some companies wonder what to do about data management now that gen AI is being implemented at large vendors. Should they just wait it out? Our answer is no—you shouldn’t wait it out, because, as Cam said, you need to build that muscle to understand not only how to keep your organization safe but also what solutions you should buy that will fit your needs.

Jörg Mußhoff: Besides data privacy and security, there’s also a big regulatory question. Gen AI can be biased, which raises ethical questions. In the mid- to long-term use of these technologies, what should insurance carriers focus on to avoid risk?

Cameron Talischi: First and foremost, it’s important for insurance carriers to have a comprehensive framework in place that covers major AI-related risks such as data privacy issues or issues and concerns about accuracy and hallucinations. Incidentally, insurance carriers need to account for risks that they’re exposed to via the use of gen AI by customers or other parties they interact with. The use of image generation is a good example of this because it could lead to fraudulent claims.

Regarding data privacy, it is possible to have automated routines to identify PII [personal identifiable information] and strip that data—if it’s not needed—to ensure that it doesn’t leave a secure environment. With accuracy, it’s important to, in tandem with the business, have objective measures and targets for performance. Test these in advance of the application or use case going into production, but also implement routine audits postproduction to make sure that the performance reached expected levels.

Khaled Rifai: In terms of regulation in Europe, the EU Artificial Intelligence Act has recently been passed. With room for national regulations, national regulators of the insurance industry will look at certain cases to determine standards. In my experience, the regulations are good enough for clients to work with. I wouldn’t start with high-risk cases concerning decisions that impact the life and health of the insured, but instead begin with other use cases that we’re certain we can implement in a secure, customer-friendly way. The thing to remember is that nothing is static, and the ongoing process of shaping regulations means taking things one step at a time.

Cameron Talischi is a partner in McKinsey’s Chicago office, and Jörg Mußhoff is a senior partner in the Berlin office, where Khaled Rifai is a partner.

Explore a career with us

Related articles.

Headshots of Jörg Mußhoff and Fritz Nauck

McKinsey insurance leadership on 2024 trends and innovations

A thumb and an index finger form a circular void, resembling the shape of a light bulb but without the glass component. Inside this empty space, a bright filament and the gleaming metal base of the light bulb are visible.

A generative AI reset: Rewiring to turn potential into value in 2024

Image of a forest fire burning on a hillside, threatening houses below the blaze, with thick smoke and flames swirling and reaching for the sky.

Navigating shifting risks in the insurance industry

Our malpractice insurance systems, including payments, will be unavailable from 11:30 a.m. on 8/30 through 9/2 as we transition to our new policy portal. Please see our FAQ for more information. .

A woman looks at a checklist on a clipboard

Health Insurance Audit Causes DC to Close Practice

What happens when a health insurance provider questions your coding? For one rural doctor, it meant the worst possible outcome.

Posted in Case Studies on Monday, August 19, 2024

Whether it's taxes or insurance, no one likes to be audited—and that's especially true for chiropractors and other health care providers, who are susceptible to insurance audits by the government (such as for Medicaid or Medicare) or by private insurance companies. 

The health care industry has seen an increasing trend in the number of audits conducted nationwide—and they're not optional. Broadly, these audits serve two purposes. First, they aim to root out fraud, abuse, and waste in the health care system. In so doing, they also seek to aid practitioners in fostering proper medical billing and charting practices in compliance with applicable laws.

There are two general forms of health insurance audits:

  • Pre-payment review - the provider’s claims for payment by the insurer are reviewed before any payment is issued
  • Post-payment review - the provider's claims are reviewed after issuance of payment

Often, a provider will be subject to a pre-payment review because of a prior unfavorable post-payment review decision.

Audits are often initiated through official correspondence notifying the practitioner of the insurer's intent to review a portion of the practitioner’s records concerning their insured. The most common risk areas insurers look for when auditing are the lack of medical necessity or documented corroboration for care, coding errors, and the failure to abide by the insurer’s specific policies and guidelines.

If the provider is found to have acted inconsistent with insurer guidelines, the insurer will seek to recoup the payment issued for the care. Government-led audits, such as for Medicare, provide a myriad of appeal processes which can result in federal judicial review. Private insurers also have an appeal process, but this review is likely conducted by an insurance-affiliated panel after an employee or team for the insurer conducted the audit. In either case, the at-fault provider is exposed to significant financial exposure and professional risk.

Dr. Livia Worrel owns her own practice in a rural community with limited access to chiropractic care. She employs a part-time receptionist, but otherwise operates her practice completely independently. Because of her rural location, she is frequently sought out by patients and is approved by various regional and national insurers, who she bills for payment of the care she provided.

Even with this steady referral and approval, market factors prevent Dr. Worrel from having a strong clientele, and any significant disruption to her stream of patients, or the fees she recovers for her care, could have a disproportionate impact on her business.

Dr. Worrel Gets Audited  

More than half of Dr. Worrel’s patients are insured by a regional insurer. The regional insurer has strict charting, coding, and reporting guidelines. Agreeing to treat patients insured by the regional insurer means Dr. Worrel has agreed to abide by these policies. As her practice continued to grow, the detail and clarity of her chart notes and patient records began to decline.

In August 2023, when she submitted claims for health insurance repayment, the insurer challenged her reporting and charting. Eventually, she received an audit notice from the insurer who then sent two investigators to her rural practice, seeking copies of select patient records. Specifically, auditors sought records of about 50 insured patients, which represented 2,000 claim lines for an 18-month period in 2022-2023. Dr. Worrel did not contact an attorney and did not organize her records as requested.

When the audit team arrived at her practice, Dr. Worrel was flustered and did not provide complete records. Those she did provide were inconsistent with the insurer's guidelines. For example:

  • Failed to document a diagnosis in her chart notes
  • Did not clearly indicate whether treatment rendered was “active” or “maintenance"
  • Codes were inconsistently reported or applied
  • Engaged in “chart cloning,” or reused the same entries for multiple appointments and patients

In sum, the insurer concluded Dr. Worrel inappropriately billed the insurer for the treatment rendered to these select patients.

Dr. Worrel Faces a $55,000 Penalty

Taking the data found from the select patient records, the insurer concluded the records contained violations significant enough that an overpayment clawback of $55,000 was necessary for payments made on all claims made to the insurer.

In other words, according to the insurer, the deficiencies and discrepancies in the charting of select patients led to questions about the authenticity and accuracy of claims for all patients resulting in a post-payment review and repayment penalty of nearly the entire amount paid to Dr. Worrel for her treatment.

A Pre-Payment Review Structure is Implemented

Additionally, issues with Dr. Worrel’s compliance with the recordkeeping requirements caused the insurer to conduct a weekly pre-payment review of all claims for the fourth quarter. The insurer continued to apply their guidelines, and Dr. Worrel continued to struggle with compliance, resulting in a nearly 53 percent reduction between Dr. Worrel's claims for payment to the insurer, and the amount paid by the insurer.

Ramifications

Dr. Worrel only contacted an attorney after the audit findings were shared, and only to aid in an appeal of their findings. While she was within her rights to appeal, the severity of the initial penalty was likely too significant to overcome; once auditors reach their conclusions, there is little incentive for the insurer to compromise any amount they feel is rightly owed to them.

Dr. Worrel’s attorneys were able to negotiate and successfully challenge some of the audit findings and reduce the overpayment amount by about $15,000. But even then, as a solo practitioner in a rural community, the overpayment was insurmountable. Coupling the $40,000 penalty with continued reductions to her billing submissions, Dr. Worrel was forced to close her practice and file for bankruptcy.

What Can We Learn

Contact your malpractice insurance carrier.  Your malpractice policy may have coverage that can help with the burden of a health insurance audit. In NCMIC's case, it's called the Audit and Legal Defense Endorsement for Chiropractors and includes coverage for Wrongful Billing and Related Proceedings (including private health insurance company billing audits).

Responsiveness to audits. Frustrating as they are, health insurance audits against providers are a reality. More often than not, however, an insurance audit does not suggest or indicate you or your practice has engaged in improper behavior or are otherwise not following protocols. But how you respond is important and can have long-lasting effects. Accordingly, it is important to take the following from this real-life example:

  • Pay attention to your audit notice.  Make sure you understand its scope, its date range, your due date, and what records are to be reviewed.
  • Use your resources. If you operate a multi-provider or high-volume clinic, make sure you immediately notify your records and compliance department. If you are a sole practitioner, it is recommended you retain a healthcare attorney to advise and represent your interests in the audit. This allows you to focus on the care you provided and aids your response to the auditors.
  • Be responsive and in compliance with what the audit seeks.  Partial records or answers will likely rouse suspicions and prolong your audit. If you cannot locate all the documents immediately, request an extension; partial answers are never recommended. Do not respond to your audit unless and until your production is complete and responsive.

Recordkeeping. Poor record-keeping and charting not only weaken your position, but can also have disastrous effects to your practice. Whether your practice is large or small, whether you are a solo practitioner or part of a clinic, as the practitioner you are responsible for your charting and recordkeeping. Make sure you are aware of all charting, coding, and reporting requirements for respective health insurers.

Take your time when writing and reviewing chart notes.  Avoid duplication and sloppy charting and reporting. Learn, understand, and correctly apply the billing codes, and avoid disorganization. Taking a few extra minutes to ensure your records are accurate and complete can save you a lot of headaches. The more organized and prepared you are throughout your practice, the more likely you are to respond positively to an audit (and avoid audits in the future!).

Plan for the future and minimize your risk. Once the audit is complete, and after you receive your audit report, you should thoroughly review and correct the issues found during the audit. Use the results of the audit as an educational tool for understanding proper practices and training both for you and your staff. Not only does this make you a more responsive and diligent practitioner, but it also minimizes your future risk.

Consider an attorney or auditing contractor. You may want to   invest resources in your documentation and billing compliance by retaining an attorney or auditing contractor to perform a periodic spot audit to ensure compliance with the obligations imposed by the insurer. This action may allow you to foresee future issues, plan ahead, fix mistakes before they compound, and reduce the risk of an overpayment and reimbursement determination.

Taking the time and investing in resources on the front end can help avoid exponentially more time, money, and resources on the back end trying to contain an audit and avoid a significant overpayment.

Additional Resources

Article: What to Do Immediately if Notified of an Insurance Audit

Joseph A. Pickels is an Attorney with Brisbee & Stockton, LLC in Hillsboro, Oregon. He focuses his practice on healthcare and professional liability defense and represents healthcare providers and employers before state and federal courts, administrative and licensing boards, and with OSHA and HIPAA compliance in Oregon and Washington.

Resources by Topic

  • Continuing Education
  • Coronavirus
  • Malpractice Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Personal Insurance
  • Financial Products
  • Chiropractic Resources
  • Naturopath Resources

Knowledge to keep you sharp

Whether you're looking for articles, videos, resources, or tools on the business aspects of starting or growing a chiropractic practice, we're here for you.

Case Study: Ruptured Breast Implant Claim is a Bust

Read more articles

the Institute of Development Studies and partner organisations

Factors that affect adoption of Weather index insurance and its intensity: The case of Kola Tembien wereda, Tigray Northern Ethiopia

Copyright holder, usage metrics.

Mekelle University, Ethiopia

COMMENTS

  1. PDF Understanding how insurance works: A case study about Lucy

    Without insurance, the appointment cost $150 and the eye drops cost $90. Vision. Yes. $30 copay for doctor visit; $10 copay for prescription. Summarize the costs of Lucy's deductibles, copays, and premiums: Lucy paid a total of $2,930 for the incidents that year. Without any insurance, she would have paid $6,620.

  2. Elevating customer experience: A win-win for insurers and customers

    In search of answers, McKinsey launched a survey of more than 8,500 insurance customers of the 40 largest North American insurance carriers across the life and property and casualty (P&C) segments (see sidebar, "About the research"). The results were clear: customer experience is a strong predictor and driver of financial and organizational ...

  3. Insurance Case Study: Recovering from Property Damage & Employee Injury

    In this case study, an accident caused by a customer resulted in serious employee injuries and significant property damage. Background. At about 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday, July 23, 2014, a patron was leaving a pub in southeastern Wisconsin. Intending to pull straight out of his parking stall, he accidentally put his vehicle into reverse and ...

  4. Insurance Case Studies: The Ultimate Guide

    Insurance case studies provide buyers with the solid facts, figures and performance examples they need to make a purchasing decision. What Is a Case Study? A case study is a powerful marketing tool that is often used in the middle or bottom of the sales funnel, to help buyers develop a preference for your offering. Case studies increase buying ...

  5. Insurance Digital Transformation: Case Study

    In this insurance digital transformation case study, our design thinking practice drives impactful results to the client's bottom line and customer experience. JANUARY 29, 2018. Home Insights Insurance Insurance Digital Transformation: Improving the Customer Experience; As data analytics transform the global business community at a rapid pace ...

  6. Insurance 2030—The impact of AI on the future of insurance

    The state of insurance in 2030. AI and its related technologies will have a seismic impact on all aspects of the insurance industry, from distribution to underwriting and pricing to claims. Advanced technologies and data are already affecting distribution and underwriting, with policies being priced, purchased, and bound in near real time.

  7. Case studies: Innovation journeys with four leading auto insurers

    These customer stories help demonstrate four keys to success that can help personal and commercial auto insurers accelerate competitiveness: Speed, accuracy, scale, and a great customer experience. Read our case studies to learn more. Recently published case studies describe the journeys of four insurers with Verisk's innovative personal and ...

  8. Understanding how insurance works: A case study about Lucy

    Read about how the insurance process works and discover what roles the insurance company and the policyholders play. Review information about specific types of insurance policy coverage and costs. Evaluate a case study to see how one policyholder's insurance choices affected her financially. Write an advice email about the value of insurance ...

  9. Case Study 4: The Digital Transformation of Insurance

    Abstract. Digital is providing great opportunities for insurance firms. The ability to collect and analyze ever-increasing quantities of data makes it possible to provide insurance that is highly personalised, and AI is enabling claims to be processed faster and more accurately than ever before. However, there are also threats for market ...

  10. Epsilon

    A Fortune 500 insurance company wanted to drive auto insurance policies by reaching only qualified, net-new leads that displayed in-market behavior. ... Case studies; Using life event triggers to drive auto insurance policies . Delivering real results for the client. 17 below cost per lead benchmark from agency partner. 6.3M+

  11. Insurance Case Studies

    Case Study Strategic Portfolio Repositioning. Working closely with a leading multiline insurance company, we followed a comprehensive four-step process to reposition its traditional core portfolio. By incorporating more diversified exposures, including illiquid assets, we enhanced book yield while meeting the client's objectives.

  12. Case study: How AI automated insurance claims

    The EY team's AI solution is driving accelerated claim processing, deepened customer relationships, and an enterprise-wide modernization. 3. The insurance firm now benefits from near real-time processing of claim documents. Since the solution's implementation, a remarkable 70% of the documents fed into the system are correctly extracted and ...

  13. Insurance claims estimator uses AI for efficiency case study

    How insurance claims estimators can use AI to increase efficiency, reduce cycle time and improve customer experience. Our Role: PwC helped an insurtech company use AI and analytics to speed up their claims estimation process. Industry: Financial Services, Fintech. Services: Emerging Tech, Artificial Intelligence Digital, Technology.

  14. PDF Case Study: Insurance Leading insurance company clears claims fast with

    Leading insurance company clears claims fast with process optimization. We enabled our client to deliver a better customer experience, reduce its costs and improve productivity by applying lean principles, optimal sourcing, automation and organization redesign to its claims processing. Claims processing operations for our client, a major multi ...

  15. Business Insurance Case Studies

    call 888-576-2438, ext. 5522, or email [email protected]. contact us today. Browse our various business insurance case studies to see the positive impact we've had and how we can safeguard your livelihood. Read more.

  16. Future of Motor and Home Insurance Survey

    Case study: purchase-embedded car insurance 8. From December 2019, all new MINIs sold in the UK came with three months' free motor insurance. After the three-month period, drivers are automatically covered via a monthly subscription. The product is available from MINI retailers at the point of sale. BMW Group Financial Services, the insurer ...

  17. Whole Life Insurance In A Lifetime Financial Plan: The Case Study

    It offered a 4.56 percent payout rate. In this case study, we use income annuities for males and couples, and we must also account for the fact that the annuity will not be purchased for twenty ...

  18. Health Insurance

    Case. Case Walkthrough. Start your case study practice now with this Booz Allen Hamilton case study. Case Intro. A health insurance company experienced a loss of $40M this year, after recording a $40M profit last year. The company is in only one line of business, Commercial Risk Insurance, in only one region. They have several direct competitors.

  19. Insurance insights, research and resources

    Research insights for the insurance industry. Fresh, relevant, and laser-focused on key insurance trends and concerns, our reports are driven by extensive primary and secondary data from across the industry. Our executive partners provide the detailed analysis and predictions you need to make informed decisions and build for the future.

  20. Advanced analytics in the insurance industry

    Case studies Advanced analytics in the insurance industry Global insurer client spotlight ... In the many decades since, the insurance business' very existence has depended on actuaries' abilities to make smart decisions based on data. One client, an insurer, is one of the world's largest providers of insurance solutions globally. ...

  21. Case Studies: Successful Underwriting Strategies

    Case Study 1: Utilizing data analytics. Data analytics plays a crucial role in the underwriting process, enabling underwriters to make more informed decisions based on data-driven insights. ... One insurance company used predictive modeling to analyze customer data and identify high-risk profiles, allowing them to adjust premiums accordingly.

  22. Insurance Industry Segments

    Infosys helped Reduce Cycle-Time to launch new services by 25%. Self-Service Platform for Faster Time-To-Market and Enhanced Customer Satisfaction. Enabling a 360 Degree Customer view Increases Servicing Efficiency. Data-Masking Solution Lowers Risk, Reduces Costs for Leading Global Insurer.

  23. PDF CASE STUDY #6 LIFE INSURANCE CASE STUDY

    Total Life Insurance Needs Total needs Minus total assets Additional Life Insurance Needed. $ 818,000 $ 247,000RecommendationsBased on this review, it is suggested that Kevin should purchase at least a. additional $247,000 of life insurance. The insurance professional would give advice and explain several options available to the family bu.

  24. PDF Case study: Insurance

    Case study: Insurance REJECTION OF INSURANCE CLAIM AND COVERAGE REVOKED Themes: Home Insurance, Loss adjustment-cause of damage, customer obligation to provide accurate and complete answers to questions, customer obligation to act in good faith. Mrs M contacted her insurance broker to file a claim for damage to the roof of her home. The

  25. Gen AI insurance use cases: A comprehensive approach

    Despite forging ahead with generative AI (gen AI) use cases and capabilities, many insurance companies are finding themselves stuck in the pilot phase, unable to scale or extract value.Jörg Mußhoff sat down with Cameron Talischi and Khaled Rifai to discuss how organizations can escape "pilot purgatory" by leveraging traditional AI and robotic process automation in addition to gen AI; the ...

  26. Health Insurance Audit Causes DC to Close Practice

    Case Study: Ruptured Breast Implant Claim is a Bust Article | Case Studies Feeling a "pop" during a chiropractic treatment is quite normal—but in the case of this patient, the sensation was caused by a ruptured breast implant... DC's Care and Concern Matter to Judge Case Studies | Case Studies A patient suffered a stroke after experiencing neurological symptoms following a chiropractic ...

  27. Chorley fraudster jailed for bogus home insurance claims

    A serial fraudster who pocketed £12,000 from bogus home insurance claims has been jailed. Joel Mtebe, of Chorley, was first sentenced in 2017, after he made 15 fraudulent claims on home insurance ...

  28. Factors that affect adoption of Weather index insurance and its

    Weather index micro insurance mechanisms are highly recognized as preferable ways to finance the drought risk. The objective of this paper is to analyze factors that affect adoption of weather index insurance and to examine the amount of insurance in Kola Tembien-wereda of Tigray Region. The study uses Heckman two- stage model to examine this issue. First, we determine the factors which affect ...